Constitutionalism in Asia in the Early Twenty-First Century

(Greg DeLong) #1

triggered intense political confrontation, partisan fights, and Constitutional Court


rulings against the backdrop of contentious politics in a new democracy. Concerns


of accountability also surfaced regarding whether and to what extent the unity


of the administration would be derogated for the purpose of establishing the


NCC.^61 Despite all the controversies, however, the creation of the first independent


commission signified Taiwan’s great leap toward a new era of administrative


reform.


The empowerment of the judiciary is another recent accomplishment of global


constitutional convergence. Similar to establishing an independent commission,


for emerging democracies, empowering the judiciary is a way to assuage political


imbroglios and uphold justice. In newly emerging democracies, intense political


disputes usually arise and require the judiciary to intervene. Especially in a


presidential democracy, where the president shoulders not only the function of


acting as the head of state, but also the role of chief executive, the winner-take-all


institution nearly assures political animosity and severe confrontation. In Taiwan,


the constitutional revision of 2005 further invested in the Constitutional Court the


power to adjudicate disputes regarding presidential impeachment, a change that


clearly corresponded to the global trend of empowering courts to resolve highly


charged political disputes.
62


Government reform and access to information


Globalization appears to be a key driving force for recent government innovation


that has taken place in many developed and developing countries.^63 Governments


have undertaken reforms over the last two decades while their respective purpose,


intensity, measures and timing have varied from one to another. The stated link of


these reforms to globalization has been divergent, and reform measures appear to


have borne strong connotations of the nature of globalization and the dynamics


of global governance. These reforms involve a common outcry for good govern-


ment in terms of integrity, competence, and quality of performance in the dis-


charge of public functions. They included organizational, operational, and process


reforms, as well as new ways of managing human resources. Concurrently, related


issues, including access to information and government transparency, also surface


as focal points of discussion. Aside from meeting the dynamics of global


(^61) J.Y. Interpretation No 613 ( 2006 ), available atwww.judicial.gov.tw/constitutionalcourt/EN/
p 03 _ 01 .asp?expno= 613.
(^62) Chang, “Strategic judicial response,” 886.
(^63) Concerning government reform in the trend of globalization, see Jiunn-rong Yeh, “Glob-
alization, government reform and the paradigm shift of administrative law” ( 2010 ), 5 ( 2 )
National Taiwan University Law Review 113 (arguing that current government reforms have
not been comprehensive in their response to globalization, and that massive flows and
varying kinds and degrees of convergence require not only domestic government reforms
but also transnational collaboration).


A decade of changing constitutionalism in Taiwan 161

Free download pdf