Constitutionalism in Asia in the Early Twenty-First Century

(Greg DeLong) #1

amended constitution introduced a mechanism of veto of all ordinances of the


NASC: the President of State can


propose to the NASC to revise its ordinances within ten days from the


date these ordinances were passed; if such ordinances are still voted for


by the NASC against the State President’s disapproval, the State Presi-


dent shall report it to the NA for decision at its nearest session.^27


Additionally, the amended constitution withdraws the authority of the NASC to


sanction proposals of the prime minister concerning the appointment and dismissal


of deputy prime ministers, cabinet ministers, and other members of the Govern-


ment in the intervals between sessions of the NA.^28 The new constitution exclu-


sively authorized the NA to sanction the appointment and dismissal of senior


governmental officials.


Apart from the functions of the legislative branch, there are also some consti-


tutional revisions which adjusted the functions of the executive branch. Since the


year 2000 , due to the impact of globalization, Vietnam has experienced dynamic


international co-operation, both bilateral and multilateral, which has significantly


involved the executive role. Meanwhile, the old constitution limited the authority


of the Government concerning international law. To allow the Government to


more actively participate in transnational legal affairs, the revised constitution has


empowered the body to negotiate and conclude international agreements in the


name of the State of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam, except for international


agreements negotiated and concluded by the President of State.
29


Challenging a Soviet institution: limiting the procuracy’s jurisdiction


The procuracy (vien kiem sat), an institution endemic in the socialist pedigree,


arguably imputed to V.I. Lenin’s contrivance, was introduced in Vietnam as early


as 1959.^30 Prior to the 2001 constitutional amendment, the procuratorial system in


Vietnam was closely patterned on the Soviet prototype. Organizationally, the


Vietnamese procuratorial branch is independent of the three traditional legislative,


executive, and judicial branches. The branch consists of the supreme people’s


procuracy, local people’s procucacies arranged parallel to the local governments,


and military procuracies. The institution is vested with two categories of authority:


general supervision (kiem sat chung), and criminal investigation and prosecution.


General supervision is the substantial authority of the procuracy. The general


supervision function of the procuracy in Vietnam is contemplated to implement


the Soviet principle of “socialist legality” (phap che xa hoi chu nghia). In the Soviet


(^271992) constitution, Art. 103 (revised). (^281992) constitution, Art. 90 (revised).
(^291992) constitution, Art. 112 (revised).
(^30) For the creation of this institution in Vietnam, see George Ginsburg, “The genesis of the
people’s procuracy in the Democratic Republic of Vietnam” ( 1979 ) 5 Review of Socialist
Law 179.


Constitutional developments in Vietnam 201

Free download pdf