Constitutionalism in Asia in the Early Twenty-First Century

(Greg DeLong) #1

Front for an Independent, Neutral, Peaceful, and Cooperative Cambodia) or


FUNCINPEC, founded by Prince Sihanouk; the Khmer People’s National Liber-


ation Front (KPNLF) led by former prime minister Son Sann; and the surviving


Khmer Rouge army and leadership.^45


The 1991 peace accord and the 1993 constitution


In October 1991 , the warring political factions signed a major peace accord and


invited the United Nations to intervene in Cambodia. The United Nations Transi-


tional Authority in Cambodia (UNTAC) was mandated to create a neutral political


environment for free and fair elections. Under Annex 3 to the 1991 Paris Peace


Agreement, a constituent assembly consisting of 120 members was to be created


within three months of the general election to ‘complete its tasks of drafting and


adopting a new Cambodian Constitution and transform itself into a legislative


assembly which will form the new Cambodian Government’.^46


UNTAC held general elections for the 120 -member Constituent Assembly in


May 1993 , and FUNCINPEC won fifty-eight of the 120 seats, leaving Hun Sen’s


Cambodian People’s Party (CPP) with fifty-one seats and the KPNLF with ten


seats. FUNCINPEC’s majority in the Constituent Assembly proved problematic as


the CPP – who controlled all the state’s institutions and apparatus – were reluctant


to surrender control. Negotiations for the drafting of the Constitution proved


difficult. In the end, the Constitution was not drafted by the Assembly but instead


by a twelve-member multiparty committee^47 formed to draft the Constitution.^48


Menzel describes the difficulties as follows:


Despite massive criticism by the media and NGOs about the secrecy


surrounding the deliberations, they remained widely confidential.


The committee had no spokesperson and members were not allowed


to speak publicly about the process. Even the other members of the


Constituent Assembly were not informed about the drafting process


in detail! Foreign influence was blocked from the beginning of


the committee’s work and the draft for a ‘bill of rights’ prepared


by the UNTAC Human Rights Component was not even disseminated


to the members of the Constituent Assembly. In the end there were two


options, one republican (seemingly favoured by CPP) and one monar-


chic (seemingly favoured by FUNCINPEC). Hun Sen and Ranariddh


travelled to consult with former King Sihanouk in Pyong Yang


(^45) Sorpong Peou, ‘Cambodia: after the Killing Fields’, in Funston,Government and Politics
in Southeast Asia,p. 36 at 38.
(^46) Art. 1 , Annex 3 , Paris Peace Agreement, 23 October 1991.
(^47) Of these, six were members of FUNCINPEC, five were members of the CPP and one was
a member of the Buddhist Liberal Democratic Party.
(^48) Menzel, ‘Cambodia: from civil war’, at 48.


Constitutionalism in Burma, Cambodia and Thailand 231

Free download pdf