People
&Markets
17
Rothschild
& Co pairs
up to work on US
energy deals with
Intrepid Financial
Partners, where golfer
Phil Mickelson is an
advisor
17
Wells Fargo
chooses Paris
as its EU trading hub
after Brexit, as the
French capital sees
its popularity among
bankers improve
15
BMO Capital
Markets
promotes investment
bankers Susan
Wolford and Patrick
Kratus in its US
investment bank arm
FRONT STORY RESULTS
Goldman, Morgan Stanley take the cake
Pair take banking market share as BAML struggles
)NVESTMENTûBANKINGûREVENUEûWASûmATûACROSSû
THEûlVEûLARGESTû53ûBANKSûINûTHEûTHIRDû
QUARTER ûBUTûBENEATHûTHEûCALMûTOP
LINEû
number GOLDMAN SACHSûANDûMORGAN STANLEY
OUTPERFORMEDûRIVALSûTOûWINûMARKETûSHARE
4HEûPUREûPLAYûINVESTMENTûBANKSûSTEPPEDû
UPûTOûTAKEûADVANTAGEûOFûPROBLEMSûATûBANK OF
AMERICA MERRILL LYNCH ûWHICHûCONTINUEDûTOû
STRUGGLEûALONGûAFTERûRECENTLYûCHANGINGûTHEû
HEADûOFûITSûCORPORATEûANDûINVESTMENTûBANK
)NVESTMENTûBANKINGûREVENUEûACROSSûTHEû
lVEûBANKSûINûTHEûTHIRDûQUARTER ûINCLUDINGûJP
MORGANûANDûCITIGROUP ûWASû53BN ûmATû
FROMûAûYEARûAGOû2EVENUESûWEREûBUOYEDûBYûAû
ûJUMPûINûEQUITYûUNDERWRITINGûACROSSûTHEû
lVEûBANKS ûBUTûTHATûWASûWIPEDûOUTûBYûAû
DECLINEûINûDEBTûUNDERWRITINGûANDû-!û
ADVISORY
'OLDMANûANDû-ORGANû3TANLEYûWEREûABLEû
TOûPOSTûGAINSûINûTHEûQUARTERûASûREVENUESû
TUMBLEDûATû"!-,ûANDû#ITI
BUOYANT ECM
'OLDMANSûINVESTMENTûBANKINGûREVENUEûOFû
53BNûINûTHEûQUARTERûWASûUPûûFROMûLASTû
YEAR
4HEûBANKSû-!ûREVENUESûOFû53Mû
WEREûUPûûFROMûAûSTRONGûYEAR
AGOûQUARTERû
%#-ûREVENUESûMOREûTHANûDOUBLEDûTOû
53MûASû)0/ûACTIVITYûACCELERATED û
SUPPORTEDûBYûSTRONGûACTIVITYûINû!SIA ûTHEû
BANKûSAIDû2EVENUEûINûDEBTûUNDERWRITINGû
FOLLOWEDûTHEûWIDERûTREND ûFALLINGûûFROMûAû
YEARûAGOûTOû53M
h'OLDMANSûTRADITIONALûSTRENGTHûASûANû
INVESTMENTûBANKINGûlRMûISûBEINGû
REINFORCED vûSAIDû2AFFERTYû#APITALûSTRATEGISTû
$ICKû"OVE
-ORGANû3TANLEYûSAWûTHEûBESTû
IMPROVEMENTûFROMûLASTûYEARûOFûTHEûMAJORû53û
BANKS ûPOSTINGûAûûINCREASEûINûINVESTMENTû
BANKINGûREVENUEûTOû53BN
)TSûTHIRD
QUARTERû$#-ûREVENUEûROSEûû
TOû53MûnûAûSURPRISINGûBRIGHTûSPOTû
CONSIDERINGûDEBTûUNDERWRITINGûREVENUEû
FELLûûACROSSûALLûlVEûBANKSûFROMûAûYEARû
AGO
)Nû-!û-ORGANû3TANLEYSûREVENUEûSLIPPEDû
ûTOû53MûCOMPAREDûWITHûAûRELATIVELYû
STRONGûYEAR
AGOûQUARTERû)Nû%#-ûITûTOPPEDû
RIVALSûWITHûREVENUEûOFû53MûUPûû
FROMûAûYEARûAGO
h!CTIVITYûREMAINEDûHEALTHYûACROSSû
PRODUCTSûANDûREGIONSûWITHûPARTICULARû
STRENGTHûINû)0/SvûSAIDûCHIEFûlNANCEûOFlCERû
*ONATHANû0RUZANûh!MERICASûWASûSTRONGû
THROUGHOUTûTHEûQUARTERûWHILEû!SIAûANDû
%UROPEûSAWûSOMEûSEASONALûSLOWDOWNûINû
!UGUSTûBEFOREûAûSTRONGû3EPTEMBERv
)NûAûSTANDOUTûQUARTERûFORû%#-ûONLYû#ITIû
WASûFROZENûOUTûPOSTINGûAûûDECLINEûINûTHEû
PERIOD
"!-,SûTHIRD
QUARTERûINVESTMENTûBANKINGû
REVENUEûSLUMPEDûûFROMûAûYEARûAGOûTHEû
STEEPESTûDECLINEûAMONGûTHEûBIGûBANKS
"!-,Sû$#-ûREVENUEûOFû53MûWASû
DOWNûûFROMûAûYEARûAGOû)TûWASûTHEû
WEAKESTûQUARTERûFORûTHEûBANKûINûMOREûTHANû
TWOûYEARSûANDûTHEûWORSTûTHIRDûQUARTERûINû
SEVENûYEARS
"!-,ûHASûALSOûSTRUGGLEDûTOûSHOWûMUCHû
PROGRESSûINûTURNINGûAROUNDûITSû-!û
FRANCHISEû!DVISORYûREVENUEûWASûDOWNû
ûTOû53MûTHEûSAMEûINCOMEûASû
ATû#ITIûWHEREûREVENUESûROSEûûFROMûAû
YEARûAGO
4HEREûISûMOUNTINGûCONCERNûABOUTû"!-,Sû
-!ûPERFORMANCE
h4OMû-ONTAGû;"!-,ûCHIEFûOPERATINGû
OFlCER=ûHASûBROUGHTûINûAûNEWûLEADERûTOûHELPû
CARRYûUSûTOûTHEûNEXTûLEVELûASûWEûLOOKû
FORWARDvû#%/û"RIANû-OYNIHANûTOLDûANALYSTSû
ONûAûCALLûh7EûKNOWûWEûCANûGETûOURûFAIRû
SHAREûOUTûOFûTHATûBUSINESSûxû3OûWEûCANûDOû
BETTERûANDûWELLûJUSTûKEEPûPUSHINGûOURûWAYû
ATûITv
"!-,ûLASTûMONTHûREPLACEDû#HRISTIANû
-EISSNERûASûHEADûOFû#)"ûAFTERûEIGHTûYEARSûINû
CHARGEû-ATTHEWû+ODERûISûTAKINGûONûTHEûTASKû
OFûREINVIGORATINGûTHEûBUSINESS
"!-,SûONEûBRIGHTûSPOTûINûINVESTMENTû
BANKINGûWASûINûEQUITYûUNDERWRITINGûWHEREû
ITSûREVENUEûOFû53MûWASûUPûûFROMûAû
YEARûAGOûFORûITSûSTRONGESTûTHIRDûQUARTERûINû
THREEûYEARS
4HEûBATONûWILLûPASSûTOû%UROPEANûBANKSû
this week, with BARCLAYS, DEUTSCHE BANKûANDû
UBSûALLûDUEûTOûREPORTûRESULTS
5"3ûWILLûALSOûRELEASEûANûINVESTORûUPDATEû
BUTûMOSTûSCRUTINYûISûLIKELYûTOûBEûWHETHERû
$EUTSCHEûHASûSTOPPEDûBLEEDINGûnûANDûIFûITSû
INVESTMENTûBANKûHASûSTABILISEDûREVENUESû
WHILEûCUTTINGûSTAFFûANDûCOSTS
Philip Scipio
Source: Company results, IFR calculations based on
weighted averages
%
-1 5
0
5
10
15
20
JPM Citi BAMLGoldman MS US average
FICC Equities Advisory/underwriting
US BANKS: EQUITIES +8% ON YEAR, FICC -3%,
ADVISORY/UNDERWRITING FLAT