IFR Magazine - October 27, 2018

Sub-prime spectre haunts CLOs

„ Structured Finance Securitisation technology funnels billions into leveraged loan sector

BY CHRIS MOORE

Fears that an overheated CLO

market has fuelled a leveraged

lNANCEûBUBBLEûTHATûCOULDûLEADûTOû

AûCORPORATEûCREDITûCRUNCHûHAVEû

PUTûSECURITISATIONûBACKûUNDERû

THEûSPOTLIGHTûûYEARSûAFTERûTHEû

TECHNOLOGYûWASûCENTRALûTOûTHEû

LASTûlNANCIALûCRISIS

h)FûYOUûLOOKûATûTHEû#,/ûSPACEû

ANDûDOûBOTTOM

UPûSTRESSûANALYSISû

LIKEûWEûDIDûINûûFORû

MORTGAGESûYOUûSEEûEXACTLYûTHEû

SAMEûTHINGû

ûMANYûHIGH

YIELDû

COMPANIESûRECEIVEDûMONEYûTHATû

THEYûDONTûREALLYûDESERVEûATûSUPER

CHEAPûRATESûANDûTHEIRûLOANSûAREû

NOWûINû#,/SvûSAIDû'EORGEû

4ZIGIANNISûHEADûOFûASSET

BACKEDû

TRADINGûATûlNANCIALûADVISORYûlRMû

3TORM(ARBOUR

h!SûTHINGSûDETERIORATEû

ûANDû

EVENTUALLYûWEûWILLûMOVEûINTOû

ANOTHERûRECESSIONû

ûWEREûGOINGû

TOûSEEûDEFAULTSû3OMEû#,/SûWILLû

SUFFERûWRITEDOWNSûEASILYûUPûTOû

$OUBLEû"ûIFûNOTû4RIPLEû"v

h)TSûASûIFûWEûNEVERûLEARNû

ANYTHINGû4HEûNEWûSUB

PRIMEû

COULDûBEûCORPORATEûBORROWERSvû

4ZIGIANNISûSAID

%ARLIERûTHISûMONTHûTHEû"ANKûOFû

%NGLANDSû&INANCIALû0OLICYû

#OMMITTEEûHIGHLIGHTEDûPARALLELSû

BETWEENû53ûSUB

PRIMEûANDû

GROWTHûINûLEVERAGEDûLOANSûANDûAû

-OODYSûREPORTûINû!UGUSTû

MENTIONEDûhEERIEûSIMILARITIESv

!LTHOUGHûWARNINGûSIGNSûMAYû

BEûmASHINGûFEWû#,/û

PROFESSIONALSûHAVEûBEENûREADYûTOû

WALKûAWAYûFROMûAûSECTORûWHICHû

HASûOFFEREDûJUICYûFEESûFORû

ARRANGERSûANDûWAREHOUSESûANDû

HIGHûRETURNSûFORûEQUITYûINVESTORS

TRAIN CRASH

)NûAûWORLDûINûWHICHûQUANTITATIVEû

EASINGûHASûDEPRESSEDûSPREADSûINû

MOREûMAINSTREAMûASSETûCLASSESû

INVESTORSûHAVEûBEENûATTRACTEDûBYû

IRRESISTIBLEûYIELDSûOFFEREDûBYû#,/û

BONDSû)Nû%UROPEû#,/SûAREûNOTû

ELIGIBLEûFORûTHEû%#"SûASSETû

PURCHASEûPROGRAMMEûUNLIKEû

MOSTûCONSUMERûSECURITISATIONSû

MEANINGûYIELDSûHAVEûREMAINEDû

RELATIVELYûHIGH

!NDûASûINVESTORûDEMANDûFORû#,/û

PAPERûHASûGROWNûMOREû#,/û

MANAGERSûHAVEûSETûUPûSHOPûINû

%UROPEû

ûOFTENû53ûMANAGERSûTRYINGû

TOûBUILDûUPû%UROPEANûBUSINESSES

h)TSûLIKEûAûSLOWûTRAINûCRASHvûSAIDû

Aû#,/ûTRADERû"UTûPASSENGERSûAREû

STAYINGûONûBOARDûALTHOUGHûSOMEû

HEDGEûFUNDSûCANûEASILYûSWITCHû

AWAYûFROMûTHEûSECTORûhTHERESûANû

INCREDIBLEûAMOUNTûOFûDEDICATEDû

STRUCTUREDûCREDITûPLAYERSûTHATûJUSTû

DONTûHAVEûTHEûABILITYûTOûDOûTHATvû

THEû#,/ûTRADERûSAID

#,/ûISSUANCEûUPûTOûTHEûENDûOFû

3EPTEMBERûINûTHEû53ûSTOODûATû

53BNûALREADYûOVERTAKINGû

THEûFULL

YEARûlGUREûOFû53BNû

FORûûACCORDINGûTOû&ITCHû)Nû

%UROPEûTHEûTOTALûWASûõBNûINû

THEûSAMEûPERIODûTHISûYEARû

COMPAREDûWITHûTHEûFULL

YEARû

lGUREûOFûõBNûFORû

*USTûASûWITHû53ûSUB

PRIMEû

INVESTORûDEMANDûFORûSECURITISEDû

PAPERûHASûLEDûTOûLOWERû

ORIGINATIONûSTANDARDSûASûLENDERSû

COMPETEûFORûASSETSû3PREADSûONû

UNDERLYINGûLEVERAGEDûLOANSûHAVEû

ALSOûBEENûFORCEDûTIGHTERûANDû

RISKIERûCREDITSûHAVEûFOUNDûITû

EASIERûTOûBORROWûRAISINGû

CONCERNSûABOUTûFUTUREûDEFAULTS

h4HEû#,/SûAREûALMOSTûLIKEû

0AC-ANûANDûTHEûLOANSûAREûLIKEû

THEûPOWERûPELLETSûTHATûTHEû#,/Sû

AREûGOBBLINGûUPvûSAIDû-ICHAELû

4ERWILLIGERûAûGLOBALûPORTFOLIOû

manager at asset management

lRMû2ESOURCEû!MERICAûh9IELDSû

WILLûPUSHûLOWERûSOûLONGûASû#,/Sû

AREûPURCHASINGûLOANSû4HEREûISû

ALMOSTûNOûLIMITûTOûITv

"UTûHEûALSOûSAIDûTHATûBECAUSEû

#,/SûAREûSEMI

PERMANENTû

lNANCINGûnûTHEYûDONTûNEEDûDAILYû

Top news

Saudi funds threatened  Netflix keeps streaming cash  DIA in the headlights 

Regulators slam leveraged lending

„ Loans Volume of cash pouring into market shows no signs of abating

BY KRISTEN HAUNSS

,EVERAGEDûLOANSûAREûCOMINGûUNDERû

INCREASINGûlREûFROMûINTERNATIONALû

REGULATORSûWHOûAREûWARNINGûTHATû

LOOSENINGûLENDERûPROTECTIONSû

MARKûAûHUGEûDETERIORATIONûINû

CORPORATEûLENDINGûTHATûCOULDûPOSEû

AûSYSTEMICûRISKûTOûTHEûBANKINGû

SECTOR

*ANETû9ELLENûTHEûFORMERûCHAIRû

OFûTHEû53û&EDERALû2ESERVEûADDEDû

HERûVOICEûONû4HURSDAYûTOûAû

GROWINGûCHORUSûOFûREGULATORSû

WHOûAREûHIGHLIGHTINGûLEVERAGEDû

LOANSûASûAûPOSSIBLEûSOURCEûOFûAû

WAVEûOFûBANKRUPTCIESûASûTHEûNEXTû

DOWNTURNûDRAWSûCLOSER

2EGULATORSûUPDATEDû53û

LEVERAGEDûLENDINGûGUIDANCEûINû

ûTOûCURBûSYSTEMICûRISKûBYû

MONITORINGûANDûPOTENTIALLYû

PENALISINGûLOOSEûUNDERWRITINGû

STANDARDS

4HOSEûEFFORTSûHAVEûBEENû

RELAXEDûASûTHEû2EPUBLICANû

ADMINISTRATIONûFOCUSESûONû

DEREGULATIONûANDûASûCASHû

CONTINUESûTOûPOURûINTOûTHEû

MARKETûANDûLOANûTERMSûGROWû

EVERûMOREûAGGRESSIVE

h4HEûRECENTûSTATEMENTSûAREû

CAREFULLYûFRAMEDûANDûAPPEARû

CONSISTENTûWITHûPRIORûREGULATORYû

statements ... that leveraged

LENDINGûMUSTûBEûSUBJECTûTOû

APPROPRIATEûRISKûMANAGEMENTû

ANDûSUPPORTEDûBYûCAPITALvûSAIDû*û

0AULû&ORRESTERûAûPARTNERûATûLAWû

lRMû-AYERû"ROWN

4HEûWARNINGSûCOMEûAMIDû

INCREASEDûMARKETûVOLATILITYûASûTHEû

$OWû*ONESû)NDUSTRIALû!VERAGEûFELLû

ûFROMû-ONDAYûTOû7EDNESDAYû

ANDûTHEûOUTLOOKûFORûGLOBALûGROWTHû

INûûDIMMEDûACCORDINGûTOûAû

2EUTERSûPOLLûOFûECONOMISTSû4HEû

ECONOMISTSûWORRIEDûTHATû

TIGHTENINGûlNANCIALûCONDITIONSû

ANDûAû53

#HINAûTRADEûWARûMAYû

TRIGGERûAûDOWNTURN

REGULATORY CHORUS

9ELLENûSAIDûTHATûSHEûWASûWORRIEDû

ABOUTûTHEûSYSTEMICûRISKSû

ASSOCIATEDûWITHûLEVERAGEDûLOANSû

ADDINGûTHATûTHEREûHADûBEENûAû

HUGEûDETERIORATIONûINûSTANDARDSû

ANDûALSOûCITEDûLOOSERûCOVENANTSû

ASûAûCONCERNûINûAû&INANCIALû4IMESû

INTERVIEWûLASTûWEEK

4HEû&EDSû4ODDû6ERMILYEAûALSOû

TOLDûAû53ûLOANûCONFERENCEûONû

7EDNESDAYûTHATûREGULATORSûAREû

CONCERNEDûABOUTûLOOSENINGû

TERMSûINCLUDINGûCOVENANTSûTHEû

ABILITYûTOûRAISEûADDITIONALûDEBTû

ANDûAGGRESSIVEûADJUSTMENTSûTOû

EARNINGSûBEFOREûINTERESTûTAXû

DEPRECIATIONûANDûAMORTISATION

h4HEûPRESENCEûOFûTHESEûPRACTICESû

ESPECIALLYûWITHOUTûTHEûAPPROPRIATEû

CONTROLSûMAYûLEADûTOûSAFETYûANDû

SOUNDNESSûCONCERNSvûHEûSAID

4HEû"ANKûOFû%NGLANDûALSOû

ISSUEDûAûSTRONGûWARNINGûOVERûTHEû

GLOBALûLEVERAGEDûLOANûMARKETûINû

/CTOBERûDRAWINGûAûCOMPARISONû

WITHûTHEû53ûSUB

PRIMEûMORTGAGEû

MARKETûTHATûTRIGGEREDûTHEûû

lNANCIALûCRISIS

4HEû"O%Sû&INANCIALû0OLICYû

#OMMITTEEûSAIDûTHATûLENDINGû

STANDARDSûWEREûFALLINGûANDûTHATûITû

WOULDûMONITORûTHEûRISKSûTOûTHEû

5+ûANDûITSûBANKINGûSECTORûMOREû

CLOSELY

4HEûPUBLICATIONûOFûNOTESûFROMû

THEû&EDSû3EPTEMBERûPOLICYû

MEETINGûALSOûSHOWEDûTHATû

OFlCIALSûRAISEDûTHEûISSUEûOFû

LOOSENINGûTERMSûANDûSTANDARDSû

INûTHEû53ûLEVERAGEDûLOANûMARKETû

FOLLOWINGûREMARKSûFROMû&EDû

#HAIRMANû*EROMEû0OWELLûINû

3EPTEMBER