IFR Magazine - October 27, 2018

LIQUIDITYûnûTHEûREALûRISKûISûMOREû
WITHûHOLDERSûWITHûLOANûEXPOSUREû
THATûNEEDûDAILYûLIQUIDITYûSUCHûASû
%4&SûANDûMUTUALûFUNDS
h4HESEûAREûMOSTLYûHELDûBYû
RETAILûINVESTORSû4HEYûAREûTHEûONESû
GOINGûTOûBEûLEFTûHOLDINGûTHEûBAGv

COV-LITE
3OMEû#,/ûINVESTORSûSAYûLOWERû
RECOVERYûRATESûONûDEFAULTEDûLOANSû
AREûJUSTûASûCONCERNINGûASûTHEûLOANû
DEFAULTSûTHEMSELVESû0ROTECTIVEû
COVENANTSûINûLOANûDOCUMENTATIONû
AREûROUTINELYûWATEREDûDOWNûANDû
THESEûCOVENCNT
LITEûLOANSûAREû
EXPECTEDûTOûSEEûLOWERûRECOVERIESû
THANûFORûBETTER
PROTECTEDûDEALSû
h$Oû)ûTHINKûTHEûNEXTûCREDITû
CYCLEûWILLûHAVEûHIGHERûDEFAULTû
RATESvûASKEDûONEûVETERANû!"3û
BANKERûh3UREû7ITHûLOWERû
RECOVERIESû$ElNITELYv
4HATûCOMBINATIONûCOULDûPUTû
RATINGSûMODELSûUNDERûPRESSURE ûANDû
SOMEûEXPECTûDEALSûFROMûTHEûNEWERû
#,/ûMANAGERSûTOûSUFFERûMOST
h)ûTHINKûFORûTHEûSMALLERûGUYSûITû
COULDûBEûAûBLOODBATH vûTHEû!"3û
BANKERûSAIDûh4HEYûDONTûGETûTHEû

ALLOCATIONSûTHEYûWANTûFORû

;LEVERAGEDûLOANS=ûTHEYûLIKEûSOûTHEYû

HAVEûTOûBUYûCUSPIERûCREDITSûJUSTûTOû

RAMPûUPûTHEIRûPORTFOLIOSûANDûMAKEû

THEIRûEQUITYûHOLDERSûHAPPYv

#,/SûHAVEûBEENûAûVITALûSOURCEûOFû

lNANCINGûFORûLEVERAGEDûCOMPANIESû

OVERûTHEûPASTûFEWûYEARSû!NDûIFûLOANû

DEFAULTSûRISEûANDû#,/SûAREûHITû

SOMEûCOMPANIESûMAYûlNDû

STRUGGLEûTOûRElNANCEû

ûPOTENTIALLYû

LEADINGûTOûAûMAJORûDISLOCATIONûTOû

CORPORATEûCREDIT

h9OUûWOULDûGETûAûPULLBACKûINû

LENDINGûFORûSUREvûSAIDûAûSECONDû

#,/ûTRADERûh#,/SûxûHAVEûALLû

BEENûAûHUGEûFUNDINGûVEHICLEû;FORû

CORPORATES=ûTHEYûSTEPPEDûINû

WHENûTHEûBANKSûSTEPPEDûBACKv

4HISûISûPARTLYûBECAUSEûTIGHTERû

REGULATIONSûAFTERûTHEûlNANCIALûCRISISû

HAVEûREDUCEDûBANKSûINCENTIVESûTOû

LENDûTOûRISKIERûCOMPANIES

h)FûYOUûHAVEûAûDETERIORATIONûOFû

CREDITûQUALITYûTHEûBANKSûAREûNOTû

GOINGûTOûSTARTûSTEPPINGûFORWARDvû

THEûSECONDûTRADERûSAIDûh9OUVEû

GOTûAûCOMPLETEûSHUTDOWNûOFûTHEû

SYSTEMûATûTHATûPOINTû

ûYOUûHAVEûAû

CORPORATEûCREDITûCRUNCHv

/FûCOURSEûTODAYSûlNANCIALû

MARKETSûAREûVERYûDIFFERENTûFROMûû

YEARSûAGOûANDûTHOSEûDRAWINGû

PARALLELSûBETWEENûTHEû53ûSUB

PRIMEû

CRISISûANDûTODAYSû#,/ûMARKETûALSOû

HIGHLIGHTûTHEûDIFFERENCESû

û

PARTICULARLYûTHEûABSENCEûOFûHIGHû

LEVELSûOFûSYSTEMICûLEVERAGEûWHICHû

HELPEDûTURNûAûSUB

PRIMEûBUBBLEû

INTOûAûWORLDWIDEûlNANCIALûCRISIS

"UTûINûPLACEûOFûHIGHûLEVERAGEû

û

WHICHûMARKETSûKNEWûWASûAû

PROBLEMûBUTûONEûTHEYûHOPEDû

THEYDûBEûABLEûTOûDEALûWITHû

ûAREû

LOWûINTERESTûRATESûANDûCHEAPû

CENTRALûBANKûMONEYûWHICHû

HAVEûDONEûAûSIMILARûJOBûOFû

DISTORTINGûASSETûPRICES

ARB IN DOUBT

!FTERûENJOYINGûPOST

CRISISûRECORDû

TIGHTSûATûTHEûSTARTûOFûTHEûYEARû

%UROPEANû#,/ûSPREADSûHAVEû

WIDENEDûSTEADILYûPARTLYûBECAUSEû

THEûGLUTûOFûNEWû#,/ûMANAGERSû

HASûLEDûTOûOVERSUPPLY

4HEûOPPOSITEûISûTRUEûFORû

LEVERAGEDûLOANSûTHEMSELVESûWHEREû

SPREADSûINû%UROPEûHAVEûTIGHTENEDû

ONûAûTHINûPIPELINEû4HATûPUTSû#,/û

ARBITRAGEû

ûBETWEENûASSETûANDû

LIABILITYûSPREADSû

ûUNDERûPRESSURE

)NûTHEû53ûBLOCKBUSTERûLEVERAGEû

LOANûISSUANCEûHASûALSOûLEDûTOûMOREû

#,/ûMANAGERSûTHANûEVERûBEFOREû

"UTû53û#,/ûSPREADSûHAVEû

SIMILARLYûCOMEûUNDERûPRESSUREû

ANDûAREûNEARûTHEIRûWIDESTûLEVELSûINû

AûYEARûMAKINGûTHEûNECESSARYû

ARBITRAGEûMOREûOFûAûCHALLENGE

-ANYû%UROPEANû#,/SûALSOûRELYû

ONûAûHANDFULûOFû*APANESEûBANKSûTOû

ACTûASûANCHORûINVESTORSûFORûTHEû

4RIPLEû!ûPARTûOFûTHEûCAPITALû

STRUCTUREûANDûMARKETûPARTICIPANTSû

AREûUNSUREûWHATûWOULDûHAPPENûTOû

NEW

ISSUEûSPREADSûIFûTHATûSOURCEûOFû

FUNDINGûDRIEDûUP

.ORûHAVEûBANKSûINû%UROPEû

AVOIDEDûEXPOSUREû"ANKSûANDû

INSURANCEûCOMPANIESûPROVIDEû

WAREHOUSEûFACILITIESûFORûMANAGERSû

TOûPARKûLOANSûASûTHEYûBUILDûUPû

PORTFOLIOSûBEFOREûISSUINGû#,/Sû

ANDûTHEREûAREûTHOUGHTûTOûBEûOVERû

ûWAREHOUSESûINû%UROPEû

EXPOSEDûTOûEXECUTIONûRISKûIFûTHEû

MARKETûGOESûWRONGû„

(Additional reporting by Joy

Wiltermuth)

Source: LPC

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

1Q054Q052Q064Q062Q074Q074Q092Q104Q102Q114Q112Q124Q122Q134Q132Q144Q142Q154Q152Q164Q162Q174Q172Q

Lehman

Collapse

Overall Cov-lite Vol % of Institutional Volume

% of institutional loan issuance Covenant-lite loan issuance $bn

COVENANT-LITE LOANS HAVE BECOME THE NORM, FAR SURPASSING

PRE-CRISIS PEAK LEVELS

Strong get stronger in equities  Calsonic gears up  Chinese banks’ Tier 2 call 

For daily news stories

@ visit http://www.ifre.com

FULL STEAM AHEAD
4HEûVOLUMEûOFûCASHûPOURINGûINTOû
THEû53TRNû53ûLEVERAGEDûLOANû
MARKETûSHOWSûNOûSIGNSûOFûABATINGû
ASûINVESTORSûSEEKûmOATING
RATEûDEBTû
TOûHEDGEûAGAINSTûFURTHERûINTERESTû
RATEûRISESû4HEû&EDûHASûHIKEDûRATESû
EIGHTûTIMESûINûTHEûLASTûTHREEûYEARS
)NVESTORSûHAVEûPLOUGHEDû
MOREûTHANû53BNûINTOûLOANû
MUTUALûFUNDSûANDûEXCHANGE
TRADEDûFUNDSûINûûANDûMUCHû
MOREûVIAû#,/SûSEEûSTORYûBELOW 
!SûMOREûREGULATORSûCALLûFORû
CAUTION û0RESIDENTû$ONALDû4RUMPû
CONTINUESûTOûPUSHûFORû
DEREGULATIONû!LTHOUGHûTHEû
LEVERAGEDûLENDINGûGUIDELINESû
REMAINûINûPLACE ûFEDERALûAGENCIESû
INCLUDINGûTHEû&EDûSAIDûINû
3EPTEMBERûTHATûGUIDANCEûDOESû
NOTûHAVEûTHEûFORCEûANDûEFFECTûOFû
LAWûANDûAGENCIESûWILLûNOTûENFORCE
4HEûSHEERûWEIGHTûOFûLIQUIDITYû
targeted at the leveraged loan
MARKETûCOMBINEDûWITHûLOOSERû
REGULATIONûISûENCOURAGINGûSOMEû
ARRANGINGûBANKSûTOûBRINGûMOREû
AGGRESSIVEûDEALSûTOûTHEûMARKET

$EBTûCOMPAREDûWITHû%BITDAû

WHICHûMEASURESûLEVERAGEûONû

BUYOUTSûINCREASEDûTOûû

TIMESûINûTHEûTHIRDûQUARTERûTHEû

HIGHESTûLEVELûSINCEûTHEûSAMEû

PERIODûINûûACCORDINGûTOû

,0#ûDATA

,EVERAGEûFORû"LACKSTONEû

'ROUPSû53BNûPURCHASEûOFûAû

ûSTAKEûINû4HOMSONû2EUTERSû

&INANCIALûû2ISKûBUSINESSûWHICHû

WASûRENAMEDû2ElNITIVûANDû

INCLUDESû)&2ûANDû,0#ûWASûû

TIMESûASûOFû*UNEûûACCORDINGûTOû

-OODYSû4HEûPRIVATEûEQUITYû

lRMûSAYSûTOTALûLEVERAGEûISûJUSTû

ûTIMESûAFTERûADJUSTMENTS

3UCHûDEALSûFARûEXCEEDûTHEû

PARAMETERSûOFûTHEûORIGINALû

GUIDANCEûWHICHûLIMITEDûLEVERAGEû

TOûSIXûTIMESûANDûALSOûEVALUATEDû

COMPANIESûABILITYûTOûREPAYûDEBT

4HEûRISEûOFûCOVENANT

LITEû

LENDINGûISûALSOûEXPECTEDûTOûDRIVEû

hWORSEûTHANûAVERAGEvûRECOVERIESû

INûTHEûNEXTûDEFAULTûCYCLEû

-OODYSûSAID

h)NVESTORSûSHOULDûBEûWORRIEDû

ANDûMINDFULûOFûTHEûRISKSû

PRESENTEDûINûTHEûCURRENTûVINTAGEû

OFûLEVERAGEDûLOANSvûSAIDû%NAMû

(OQUEûAûVICEûPRESIDENTûATûTHEû

RATINGSûlRMûh#OV

LITEûISûONLYûTHEû

TIPûOFûTHEûICEBERGû4HEREûAREû

SERIOUSûDElCIENCIESûTHROUGHOUTû

THEûCREDITûAGREEMENTSv

!BOUTûûOFûTHEû53ûLEVERAGEDû

INSTITUTIONALûMARKETûWASû

COVENANT

LITEûINûTHEûlRSTûTHREEû

QUARTERSûOFûTHEûYEARûCOMPAREDû

WITHûûINû-ARCHûûWHENûTHEû

GUIDANCEûWASûUPDATEDûACCORDINGû

TOû,0#ûDATAû)Nû%UROPEûWHEREûSUCHû

LOANSûWEREûRAREûBEFOREûTHEû

lNANCIALûCRISISûTHEûNUMBERûISû

h!TûSOMEûPOINTûINVESTORSûSHOULDû

ASKûTHEMSELVESûIFûAûSENIORûSECUREDû

TERMûLOANûISûJUSTûSENIORûSECUREDûINû

NAMEûONLYvû(OQUEûSAIDûh4HEû

mEXIBILITYûPROVIDEDûINûTHESEû

DOCUMENTSûISûAûREALûRISKûTOûINVESTORSû

ACCUSTOMEDûTOûLEVERAGEûLOANSûWITHû

MOREûTRADITIONALûPROTECTIONSv „