Exploratory Study on Circular Economy Approaches A Comparative Analysis of Theory and Practice

(Rick Simeone) #1

94 4 Case Description and Within-Case Analysis


are therefore committed to protecting the environment in their daily work, as


described by the interviewee in the following quote: “There are many people that


are very committed to and motivated by outdoor spaces and they are climbers and


skiers and runners and paddlers and they want to do something good for the space


they care about.”


Another reason for engaging in circular economy is the anticipation of regula-

tory changes. The interview partner explained it as follows: “A driver is regulatory


change and being able to anticipate potential changes and regulations and not have


to move retroactively.” Since the organization already voluntarily puts a lot of effort


into implementing the circular economy it is usually several steps ahead when it


comes to changes in governmental regulations. Consequently, it is easier for the


organization to comply with upcoming regulations.


The final driver for the organization is the increased attention to circular

economy from retailers. As a young and growing company, the organization in


case Iota wants to ensure that it does not miss out on engaging in this issue which


is receiving a lot of attention within the industry. The issue of circularity has not


only become important for competitors but also for retailers who expect a certain


amount of commitment to it as explained in this quote: “Retailers are starting to


ask questions about brand image. They want to know what you are doing when it


comes to protecting the environment and how they can count on you to help them


lead on the issue of sustainability.”


4.11.3 Challenges for the Implementation


In terms of the challenges the organization in case Iota is facing, it hasn’t faced any


specific challenges with the approaches it selected to implement circular economy.


However, the interview partner identified some challenges which he expects to arise


in the future. These challenges are more systemic ones than specifically mapped to


the implementation approach pursued by the organization.


The first challenge is to rethink design of products. Products have to be designed

in a way that they are modular and can easily be reengineered into something else


at the end of their lifecycle. This requires a rethinking in the production of mate-


rials by suppliers, manufacturers and customers. The current situation is that as


soon as a material is sold the supplier does not feel any responsibility for the waste


which might arise at the end of the product life. The interviewee sees the situation


as follows: “I think one of the biggest challenge we face is the economic model where


nobody owns the material (...) this issue with the waste where we don’t legally or


technically have any responsibility for the waste once the consumer has bought it

Free download pdf