Exploratory Study on Circular Economy Approaches A Comparative Analysis of Theory and Practice

(Rick Simeone) #1

5.1 Implementation of the Circular Economy Concept 101


101

shall be achieved (Windolph et al. 2014). Literature states that internal improve-


ments also contribute to employee satisfaction and motivation which increases


productivity (Windolph et al. 2014; Ehnert 2009; Carter and Rogers 2008; Moon


2007; Mcwilliams and Siegel 2001; Daily and Huang 2001).


Additionally, multiple studies find ethical reasons responsible for companies

engaging in sustainability initiatives (Babiak and Trendafilova 2011; Brønn and


Vidaver-Cohen 2009; Graafland 2006). Motivations for engaging in sustainability


in this context can be personal moral values, the desire to make a positive con-


tribution to society’s future, or to ‘do the right thing’ (Brønn and Vidaver-Cohen


2009; Graafland 2006).


As a result of this study all identified incentives in the cases of this study are

grouped as sub-categories to the four motives identified in literature as depicted


in Table 16.


Ta b l e 16 Results of evaluation of motivation reasons categorized into four
motive groups
Drivers for Sustainability
(literature review)


Drivers for Circular Economy
(Empirical results)
Ethical considerations • Personal Interest of the founder / CEO
Company-internal
improvement

•   Potential price stability in the future
• Minimize costs
• Employees motivation to do good for the environ-
ment
Legitimacy • Mission of the Company
• Important topic for the industry
• Curiosity for new concept
• Becoming a role model for other companies
• Anticipation of regulatory changes
Market Success • First mover advantage
• Competitive advantage
• Perfect fit to product portfolio
• Increased customer value
• PR initiative
• Increasing retailer attention
• Increased product quality

Market success is the group which has the most coded motives assigned to it.


However, the table above depicts that other reasons play an important role for

Free download pdf