Exploratory Study on Circular Economy Approaches A Comparative Analysis of Theory and Practice

(Rick Simeone) #1

24 2 Theoretical Foundations


35

Fig. 2^ Overview of monetary and non-monetary benefi ts derived from literature^


As presented in Figure 2, cost savings is a monetary category identifi ed in literature.


Th e category is distinguished in cost savings achieved through (1) lower material


costs by retrieving and reusing material ( Park et al. 2010; Kienbaum Management


Consulting 2014), and (2) the reduction of other ‘non-value-added’ costs. Th e later


can be achieved e.g. through lower insurance costs, more effi cient energy use and


fewer environmental penalties ( Geng et al. 2012), lesser pollution and waste inef-


fi ciencies ( Sinkin et al. 2008; Ellen MacArthur Foundation 2012; Accenture 2014)


or reduction of warranty costs ( Ellen MacArthur Foundation 2012).


On (1): A case study undertaken by Park et al., consisting of three cases in the

information technology and electronic industries in China, distinguished between


cost reduction on corporate and inter-fi rm level. Th e results showed that on a


corporate level, production cost savings are possible by retrieving and reusing


material. On an inter-fi rm level, fi ndings show that organizations which are part


of an eco-industrial park can benefi t from material cost reduction through col-


lection, remanufacturing and reuse of materials within the park ( Park et al. 2010).


Th e Ellen MacArthur Foundation sees the potential of a reduced material bill by


“reselling and component recovery” ( Ellen MacArthur Foundation 2012, p.  75).

Free download pdf