Exploratory Study on Circular Economy Approaches A Comparative Analysis of Theory and Practice

(Rick Simeone) #1

4.8 Case Zeta 83


83

will benefit from it [engaging in circular economy]“ (see Appendix: German Quote


36). As one of the first companies in the industry to invest in it, several advantages


are gained, such as know-how advantage, technological advantage and trustful


partnerships with required suppliers.


The third driver is the expected benefit of price stability particularly for price

variations in the cotton industry. The interview partner expressed an expectation


to obtain some measure of stability by using recycled resources. Bearing the future


development of prices in mind, the usage of recycled material might even avoid


future price instabilities, as stated here: “On the other hand when we look at the


increasing prices of cotton: I think it was two or three years ago when prices for cotton


doubled therefore it is in our own interest to look for alternatives such as secondary


resources or recycled resources to gain price stability and to try to avoid an increase


in prices” (see Appendix: German Quote 37).


4.8.3 Challenges for the Implementation


One major challenge for case Zeta is technological limitations that don’t allow for


certain materials to be kept in a cycle without losing their quality. This is the case


for dyed polyester. Polyester itself can be recycled without losing its quality but as


soon as it is dyed it is almost impossible to get it neutral or white. The interviewee


explains this challenge as follows: “Currently we are not able to introduce polyester


into the cycle of material. In theory, it is possible but we have difficulties with coloring.


It is impossible to whiten dyed polyester” (see Appendix: German Quote 38).


The next challenge for the organization is lack of customer education. The ma-

jority of customers do not know about the advantages of circular economy products.


The experiences of case Zeta show that the main factors influencing customers when


deciding to purchase a product are price and design. Sustainability features are seen


as add-ons but only if the price and design of the product meet the expectations of


the customer. Only a minority of customers buy products based on their sustain-


ability features. Hence, customers need to be made aware of the additional benefits


of circular products. “On the other hand our research shows that design and price


are the main criteria in the buying decision. Sustainability or recycled resources are


only valued as add-ons but never as main criterion for mainstream customers” (see


Appendix: German Quote 39).


Another economic challenge is the high expenses incurred in the recycling of

products. It is expensive for organizations to collect worn out apparel and then to


sort it according to what condition it is in before shipping it to recycling companies


which are located mainly in Asia. The financial costs of the process mean that it is

Free download pdf