90 | June• 2018
FALSE MEMORIES
DNAtesting,saysfalsememoryplays
aroleinmorethan70percentofthe
wrongful convictions they overturn.
Intenpercentofthosecases,their
clients originally pleaded guilty,
serving an average of 14 years for
crimes that they didn’t commit.
DrJuliaShawisacriminalpsy-
chologist at London Southbank Uni-
versity and the author of popular
psycholog y bookTheMemoryIllu-
sion.Sheconductsresearchintohow
andwhyourbrainsformthesecom-
plex false memories. It’s a phenom-
enon,sheexplains,that’sfarmore
common than we might imagine.
“Weliketothinkwe’reableto
distinguish between imagination
and experiences, but
the brain can’t actu-
ally do this very well.
Certainly not once
you’ve pictured what
afantasymightfeel,
smellortastelike.
Then you’re adding in
the markers we usu-
allyusetoseparate
fact and fiction, and
you’re making them
indistinguishable.”
Ourbrainsarehometoapprox-
imately86billionneurons.Eachis
equipped with stringy arms called
dendrites, allowing them to stretch
out to other cells. Each dendrite has
‘spines’,whichactlikefingers,ena-
blingthemtoreachoutacrosssyn-
apses and communicate from one
False memory
plays a role in
70 per cent of
the Innocence
Project’s
overturned
convictions
JustadayafterBarbara’sbodywas
found, the murder was an open and
shutcase.Basedonhisconfession,a
jurysentencedPetertobetweensix
and16yearsinprison.heonlyprob-
lem? He was innocent.
Theteenager’smemoryofhis
mother’s murder was entirely false.
In1975,twoyearsafterhisconvic-
tion,Peterwassetfree,exonerated
by evidence that proved he couldn’t
have been at the scene of the crime.
Byclaimingthathe’dfailedalie-
detectortestandthatmentalillness
hadlikelycausedhimto‘blackout’the
crime, the interrogators convinced
Peter–byallaccountsaquiet,
good-natured boy who loved his
motherdearly–that
he must have been the
killer.
NotonlydidPeterbe-
lieve his interrogators,
he eventually provided
detailed memories of
the attack, explain-
ingbothhismotive
(his mother was an
alcoholic who rarely
showed him afection)
andplanfordisposing
of the weapon (tossing it behind a
nearby service station).
So why did this young man from a
sleepy town in Connecticut confess
toacrimehenevercommitted?
he Innocence Project movement
in the US, which seeks to exonerate
innocent prisoners through modern