From Inquiry to Academic Writing A Practical Guide, 3rd edition

(やまだぃちぅ) #1

344 APPENDIX | CITING AND DOCUMENTING SOURCES


Although you’ll need the manuals for complete style information, both
the MLA (http://www.mla.org/style_faq/) and the APA (http://www.apastyle
.org/learn/faqs/) maintain Web sites for frequently asked questions. Again,
before you start your research, check with your instructor to find out whether
you should use either of these styles or if there’s another style he or she prefers.
MLA and APA styles have many similarities — for example, both re -
quire short citations in the body of an essay linked to a list of sources at
the end of the essay. But it is their differences, though subtle, that are cru-
cial. To a great extent, these differences reflect the assumptions writers in
the humanities and in the social sciences bring to working with sources.
In particular, you should understand each style’s treatment of the source’s
author, publication date, and page numbers in in-text citations, and verb
use in referring to sources.

Author. MLA style requires that you give the author’s full name on first
mention in your paper; APA style uses last names throughout. The human-
ities emphasize “the human element” — the individual as creative force —
so MLA style uses the complete name at first mention to imply the author’s
importance. Because the social sciences emphasize the primacy of data in
studies of human activity, in APA style last names are deemed sufficient.

Publication Date. In-text citations using MLA style leave out the date of
publication. The assumption is that the insights of the past may be as use-
ful as those of the present. By contrast, APA style gives the date of the study
after the author’s name, reflecting a belief in the progress of research, that
recent findings may supersede earlier ones.

Page Numbers. MLA style requires that page numbers be included with
paraphrases and summaries as well as quotations (the written text is so
important that a reader may want to check the exact language of the origi-
nal). By contrast, APA style requires attribution but not page numbers for
paraphrases and summaries (it is the findings, not how they are described,
that are most important).

Verb Use. MLA style uses the present tense of verbs (“Writer X claims”) to
introduce cited material, assuming the cited text’s timelessness, whether
written last week or centuries ago. By contrast, the verbs introducing
citations in APA style acknowledge the “pastness” of research (“Writer X
claimed” or “Writer Y has claimed”) on the assumption that new data may
emerge to challenge older research.
Although it is useful to understand that different citation styles reflect
different attitudes toward inquiry and research in different disciplines, for
the purposes of your writing it is mainly important to know the style you
have to follow in your paper, and to stick to it scrupulously. Whenever you

19_GRE_60141_App_BRF_343_353.indd 344 10/31/14 4:48 PM

Free download pdf