The Price of Prestige

(lily) #1

status symbols and luxury goods 49


indicator. The Cuban regime invested a lot of effort and resources in pre­

senting Cuba as a “world medical power.” In order to promote this image,

Cuba exported health personnel to developing countries in Africa, Asia,

and Latin America.

Finally, domestic processes of classification through invidious compari­

son can affect the choice of international status symbols and vice versa.

Weinberg ( 2003 ), for example, examines the reasons behind the adoption

of the cavalry as a weapon of choice during the medieval period. He claims

that while initially successful, over time the use of a lance became waste­

ful and proved ineffective when facing infantry. It is therefore difficult to

explain the popularity of the cavalry in feudal Europe based solely on the

primary utility of the lance. Instead, he suggests an explanation that em­

phasizes the role of the horse as a conspicuously costly status symbol: “The

great expense of this tactic was an advantage, not a drawback, because

peasants could not afford a destrier and armor. The reason that foot sol­

diers were not used in battle is not that they have been ineffective, but that

they were common” (Weinberg 2003 , 58 ; see also Tucker 2001 ; Howard

2001 ). In fact, war fighting itself was a status symbol. Commoners were not

supposed to fight and were not protected by the laws of war (Keen 1965 ,

19 ). Subsequently, medieval European armies tended to replicate feudal

hierarchy on the battlefield: a knight “firmly believed that, since he was

infinitely superior to any peasant in the social scale, he must consequently

excel him to the same extent in military value. He was, therefore, prone

not only to despise all descriptions of infantry, but to regard their appear­

ance on the field against him as a species of insult to his class pride” (Oman

1885 , 102 ). As a consequence, for example, the French army resisted giving

archers a greater role in their battle plans and continued to rely on cav­

alry despite repeated calamitous defeats in Crécy ( 1346 ), Poitiers ( 1356 ),

and Agincourt ( 1415 ) (Tuchman 1978 ; George 1895 , 736 ). In the case of

the French army, domestic class structures resulted in significant military

defeats, culminating in the capture and imprisonment of the French king.

The feudal upper classes preferred an inferior tactic internationally be­

cause its cost offered a convenient venue for invidious comparison domes­

tically. In this example, domestic processes of classification defined the

types of weaponry that became prestigious internationally. Actors who

used cavalry were seen as more “civilized” than those who relied on infan­

try or archery.^15

Medieval cavalry offers a second­ image model of prestige policies.

However, the interaction between the domestic and the international can

flow in the other direction as well. The Italian tower mania is an example
Free download pdf