450 A. BASIC RICCI FLOW THEORY
where the dot denotes the metric inner product, i.e., X · Y = (X, Y) =
gijxiyj.
If gtgij = -2Rij on M x (a,w) and f: M x (a,w) --t lR, then
( ~ -:t) l\7 fl
2
= 2 l\7\7 fl
2
+ 2\7 f. \7 ( ( Ll - :t) f).
1.9. The cylinder-to-ball rule. The following is an obvious modifi-
cation of Lemma 2.10 on p. 29 of Volume One.
LEMMA A.2 (Cylinder-to-ball rule). Let 0 < L ::::; oo and let g be a
warped-product metric on the topological cylinder (0, L) x sn of the form
g = dr^2 + W (r)^2 gcan,
where w : (0, L) --t lR+ and 9can is the canonical round metric of radius 1
on sn. Then g extends to a smooth metric on B ( 5, L) (as r --t O+) if and
only if
(Vl-2.16) lim w(r) = 0,
r--+0+
(Vl-2.17) lim w' (r) = 1,
T--+0+
and
(Vl-2.18)
d2kw
r--+0+ lim d r^2 k (r) =^0 for all k EN.
1.10. Volume comparison. We recall the Bishop-Gromov volume
comparison (BGVC) theorem.
THEOREM A.3 (Bishop-Gromov volume comparison). Let (Mn,g) be a
complete Riemannian manifold with Re 2: ( n - 1) K, where K E IR. Then
for any p EM,
VolB(p, r)
VolK B(pK, r)
is a nonincreasing function of r, where PK is a point in the n-dimensional
simply-connected space form of constant curvature K and VolK denotes the
volume in the space form. In particular
(A.6)
for all r > 0. Given p and r > 0, equality holds in (A.6) if and only if B(p, r)
is isometric to B (p K, r).
If Re 2: 0, we then have the following.
COROLLARY A.4 (BGVC for Re 2: 0). If (Mn, g) is a complete Rie-
mannian manifold with Re 2: 0, then for any p E M, the volume ratio
VoI~Jp,r) is a nonincreasing function of r. We have VoI~Jp,r) ::::; Wn for all