David Bentley Hart - That All Shall Be Saved

(Chris Devlin) #1
108 Apokatastasis: Four Meditations

believed in keeping the Law of Moses but who also believed
that Jesus was the Messiah. It is for the most part, as far as I can
tell, an extravagantly allegorical "prophecy" not about the end
of history as such, but about the inauguration of a new histori-
cal epoch in which Rome will have fallen, Jerusalem will have
been restored, and the Messiah will have been given power "to
rule the gentiles with a rod of iron." And this new epoch, so
the text clearly seems to announce, will not even really lie be-
yond history as a continuing reality: There will still, it tells us,
be kings and gentile peoples beyond the walls of God's city,
walking in its light and invited to enter through its open gates.
To me, it is all a religious and political fable, principally con-
cerned with Rome and Judaea in the closing decades of the
first century, and written in extremely obscure symbols for a
community that already understood their hidden meanings.
This is not to deny that it is also of course a vivid testament to a
particular apocalyptic idiom, and so no doubt carries hints and
adumbrations of a larger set of eschatological expectations; but
I see those expectations as mostly accidental to the text's essen-
tial message, and find them hazy to the point of unintelligi-
bility. I know that this view of the matter might make the book
considerably less enjoyable for those who think it some kind of
visionary script for the end of time, a magic mirror for scrying
out things yet to come, but I cannot alter my views (since they
are almost certainly correct).
Then again, all things considered, my opinions on the
matter just might spare persons of a more chiliastic bent cer-
tain exegetical embarrassments. After all, if one chooses to
read Revelation entirely as a picture of the final judgment of all
creation, and of the great last assize of all souls, one must then
also account for the seeming paradox of a prophesied final
judgment- one that includes a final discrimination between

Free download pdf