Foreign Affairs - 11.2019 - 12.2019

(Michael S) #1
Recent Books

November/December 2019 217

in Lebanon, Iraqi militias, and the
Houthis in Yemen. With or without
nuclear weapons, Iran can project power
through much o‘ the Arab world. What it
lacks in advanced weaponry it makes up
for in granular knowledge o‘ the region,
experience Äghting various kinds o‘ wars,
and superior intelligence gathering.
Although Iranians are weary o‘ sanctions,
the government remains strong, and in
the absence o‘ an invasion by an outside
power, regime change seems unlikely.


Spear to the West: Thought and
Recruitment in Violent Jihadism
BY STEPHEN CHAN. Hurst, 2019, 176 pp.


This small tome is packed and requires
some rereading to fully grasp the argu-
ment. Chan, the founding dean o‘ the
University o“ London’s School o‘ Orien-
tal and African Studies, dismisses the
notion that violent jihadism feeds o
poverty and marginalization. Rather,
jihadism draws from a line o‘ reasoning
that is “modernist” and poses a stark
alternative to liberal globalization. Chan
dips in and out o– brie‘ sketches o‘ inÁuen-
tial thinkers (including the medieval
Sunni theologian Ibn Taymiyyah and
the twentieth-century writer and activist
Sayyid Qutb); he selects them based on
the number o‘ clicks each Ägure gets in
Internet searches. He undermines some
o– his argument by conceding that
contemporary jihadis don’t always read
these thinkers. The author outlines the
12 steps that lead to the online recruit-
ment o‘ jihadis, but he oers no evi-
dence that this method is especially
prevalent or important. Chan’s argument
can be a bit hard to follow, but it has at
least two major implications: only
those capable o‘ speaking within the


ideological terms o‘ jihadis can counter
their appeal, and counterterrorism
strategists must consider using the
Internet in ways they have not yet tried.

Asia and PaciÄc


Andrew J. Nathan


China’s New Red Guards: The Return of
Radicalism and the Rebirth of Mao Zedong
BY JUDE BLANCHETTE. Oxford
University Press, 2019, 224 pp.

Minjian: The Rise of China’s Grassroots
Intellectuals
BY SEBASTIAN VEG. Columbia
University Press, 2019, 368 pp.

A


contentious struggle between
reformers and conservatives
marked Chinese politics in the
Ärst decade o“ Deng Xiaoping’s re-
forms. That battle seemed to have
disappeared after the 1989 Tiananmen
crackdown, but in fact it had migrated
from politics to intellectual life. As the
post-Deng leadership was busy shrink-
ing the role o‘ state-owned enterprises
and pushing China deeper into the
global trading economy, intellectuals on
the left used academic conferences and
the Internet to mount critiques o‘
neoliberalism and globalization, arguing
that these policies coddled capitalists,
hurt workers, and sold out China’s
sovereignty. Although some leftists called
for a “second Cultural Revolution,” they
did not use violence, as the Red Guards
had done in an earlier era. But they
shared with the Red Guards the same
Free download pdf