START 036
but consumers might start exchanging
their dollars for Libra in order to pay
for goods and services provided by
Facebook and its partners – which
include e-commerce site eBay and
music streaming service Spotify. If a
third of the world’s population did this,
Facebook and its partners would have
in effect established its own financial
system, run according to rules it deter-
mines and subject to no government.
Of course, Libra would still depend on
government currencies to remain stable.
But that doesn’t mean governments
could control it. Quite the contrary.
The Libra reserve would be the largest
investment fund on Earth, dwarfing even
the sovereign wealth funds of oil-pro-
ducing nations. Buying and selling assets
to keep Libra’s value stable would move
currency and government bond markets.
And since it would out-gun central banks
- even the mighty US Federal Reserve –
there would be little governments
could do to protect their economies.
The Libra reserve could also influence
government policy. It could ditch assets
in currencies issued by governments
whose policies the Libra Association
disapproves of. Attempts to control
Libra could result in a collapsing
currency and rising borrowing costs.
Again, this is nothing new: big banks
and their representatives have been
trying to influence government policy
for years. But the Libra reserve would
have greater market-moving power
than any bank, past or present. Some
academics have expressed concern
that Libra could grow so large that
central banks would be forced to bail
it out if there were a run on its reserve.
My concern, however, is not so much
what central banks might do in the
event of a run on Libra, but what govern-
ments might have to do to prevent one.
Back in 2012, the Bank for Interna-
tional Settlements proposed that major
governments should both produce
enough debt to keep financial markets
functioning, and preserve the value
of that debt through cuts to public
spending and austerity measures. The
Libra Association could similarly insist
that governments not only produce
enough “safe assets” to maintain
Libra’s peg, but prioritise maintaining
the value of those assets over the
wellbeing of their populations. And if
the Libra reserve achieved dominance
in financial markets, governments
might have no choice but to comply.
If Libra became the world’s transaction
currency, and its reserve became the
dominant player in financial markets,
the Libra Association would
have the power to allow or
deny people the right to
transact – something that
is currently a government
prerogative limited by
democratic safeguards. It
could exert that power not
only over individuals, but
other companies and even
governments. The Libra
Association could break a
company that refused to use
Libra, or punish a recalcitrant
government by denying its
citizens access to the transaction services
enjoyed by a third of the world’s people.
Many have dreamed of a single global
currency that would enable people to
transact with each other seamlessly and
instantaneously. But if the only way of
achieving this is for an unaccountable
corporate elite to replace democrati-
cally elected governments, surely that’s
too high a price. Frances Coppola
PHOTOGRAPHY: ALAMY
F
THE NEW TASTE OF
SUSTAINABILITY:
MAKING BUG PROTEIN
DELICIOUS FOR FISHES
armed salmon are
surprisingly picky
eaters. Feed made
from protein-
rich milled black soldier fly
larvae (fed on supermarket
food waste) is better for
the environment than the
estimated 215,385 tonnes of
fishmeal consumed annually
by Scottish salmon – but the
fish find the carcass remains
hard to digest, says Fotis
Fotiadis, co-founder and
CTO of Cambridge-based
startup Entomics. He claims
the current process is also
wasteful – like cooking and
drying an entire cow to make
a single protein shake.
To break down the nutrients
and produce a more digestible
feed, Entomics has patented
a post-processing technique
using microbial fermentation,
dubbed Metamorphosis.
The boiled larvae are
processed automatically: first,
separators winnow out chitin,
a fibrous substance making up
the insects’ body wall; another
machine isolates the proteins
and fats for fermentation;
finally, the fermenting mix
is stirred in with bacteria and
yeast, which break proteins
down into amino acids that can
be converted into a dry powder.
The four founders of
Entomics, all graduates from
the University of Cambridge,
came up with the idea when
they entered a competition
to find a way to reuse food
waste. They won, and launched
Entomics to realise their
university project, which is
now ready for deployment at
insect farms. Tuck in, fishies...
Sabrina Weiss entomics.com
‘Libra could grow
so large, central
banks would be
forced to bail it out’
11-19-SToped.indd 36 13/09/2019 05:20