.l.R
Morgan
St».once
((1111ajcwzzlmuflhis
an/uairzm:m>
thathe
wasimererrerlIll
buying
a
pearl
.\'(
ml’-
pin.
Justa
few
wt?€k.s
1zlIt'r'.the
;eweIer
happened
upon
a
rmzgrtzficerztpearl’.
[[9
hadi!mmmfedinan
uppmprmte
sertizzg
and
SM!is’ 10
Morgan.
mgrtlser
with(2bill
for
$5,001).
‘lhefollriwing
day
the
parka/gr:
wax
remmud.
Morgan
ix‘
acrcmrtpzt/tying
note
read:
“I
likethe
pm.
butI(hm’tlike1111»
prire.[fyma
will
uccepi
theenclasezlciwrzk
for
$¢\()()0.
pleaxv
send
backtheboxwiththe
sear.’smbmkcn.
"
The
mrrzgerljcwelrerrefzmui
thedizrrkanddiy»
rriissezlthe
i?i€.\‘S€Ilg€I'
in
1li.Ygll5‘l.
Ht!
nprsmui
up
theboxtoreclaim
themmwxml
pm,
only
to
/iml
thatuhm!L-cm
rrmzovorliInin
plum’
mma
(1u'(,'kfor
.h”5,(}(l().
'1H];Hrruz,uiwwr»
li()<)l\‘orAN!,('DO’H 54
L'i,u"mr~I-‘m>|M.»\i~:,I-n..
l985
258
LAW 31
atediftheir
partner
istoo
interested
in
their
money.
Asthe
courtesan
aged,
then,
shefaced
amost
difficultfate.
NinondeLencloshadahorrorof
any
kindof
dependence.
She
early
ontastedakindof
equality
withher
lovers,
andshewouldnotsettleintoa
system
thatlefthersuchdistasteful
options.Strangelyenough,
the
system
shedevisedinits
place
seemedto
satisfy
hersuitorsasmuchasitdid
her.
The
payeur:may
havehad
to
pay,
butthe
factthatNinon
would
onlysleep
withthemwhenshewantedto
gave
them
a
thrillunavailablewith
every
othercourtesan:Shewas
yielding
outofherowndesire.The
martyrs’
avoidanceofthetaintof
having
to
paygave
themasenseof
superiority;
as
membersofNinon’s
fraternity
of
admirers,
they
also
might
some
dayexpe
riencetheultimate
pleasure
of
being
her
favari.Finally,
Ninondidnot
forceher
suitorsintoeither
category.They
could“choose”whichside
they
prefer:-ed—a
freedomflintleftthema
vestige
ofmasculine
pride.
Suchisthe
power
of
giving
people
a
choice,
orrathertheillusionof
one,
for
they
are
playing
withcards
you
havedealtthem.Wherethe
alter-
nativesset
upby
IvantheTerrible
involved
acertain
risk—-one
option
would
haveledtohis
losing
his
power——Ninon
createda.situationinwhich
everyoption
redoundedtoherfavor.Fromthe
payeurs
shereceivedthe
money
sheneededtorunhersalon.Andfromthe
martyrs
she
gained
the
ultimatein
power:
Shecouldsurroundherselfwitha.
bevy
of
admirers,
a
haremfromwhichtochooseherlovers.
The
system,though,depended
ononecriticalfactor:the
possibility,
however
remote,
that
a
martyr
couldbecomea
fawn".
Theillusionthat
riches,
glory,
orsensualsatisfaction
maysomeday
fallinto
your
victim's
lap
isanirresistiblecarrottoincludein
your
listofchoices.That
hope,
how-
ever
slim,
willmakemen
accept
themostridiculous
situations,
becauseit
leavesthemthe
allimportantoption
of
adream.Theillusionof
choice,
marriedto
the
possibility
offuture
good
fortune,
willlurethemoststub
bornsuckerinto
yourglittering
web.
KEYSTOPOWER
Wordslike
“freedom,”
“options,”
and“choice”evokea
power
of
possibility
far
beyond
the
reality
ofthebenefits
they
entail.Whenexamined
closely,
thechoiceswehave——inthe
marketplace,
in
elections,
inour
jobs»-tend
to
havenoticeablelimitations:
They
areoftenamatterofa
choice
simply
be-
tweenAand
B,
withtherest
ofthe
alphabet
out
ofthe
picture.
Yetas
long
as
thefaintest
mirage
ofchoiceflickers
on,
we
rarely
focusonthe
missing
options.
We“choose”tobelievethatthe
game
is
fair,
andthatwehaveour
freedom.We
prefer
nottothinktoomuchaboutthe
depth
ofour
liberty
to
choose.
This
unwillingness
to
probe
thesmallness
of
ourchoicesstemsfrom
the
factthattoomuchfreedomcreatesakindof
amdety.
The
phrase
“un-
limited
options”
sounds
infinitelypromising,
butunlimited
options
would
actuallyparalyze
usandcloudour
ability
tochoose.Ourlimited
range
of
choicescomfortsus.