Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain_ Environment, Identity, and Empire in Qing China\'s Borderlands

(Ann) #1
Borderland Manchus were a particularly valuable human resource

formed under these conditions. They embodied the empire’s Manchu-

rian borderland, ideally as its quintessential northeastern hunter-soldier

unspoiled by residence in the agro-urbanized south.“New Manchus”

were the most militarized manifestation of borderland Manchu iden-

tity, which also included indigenouspelt tributary peoples not normally

subject to military service. New Manchus ideally combined vernery

skills in service of the dynasty’s regional order.^2 This distinction

in identity differentiates those indigenous groups who left trapping

behind when they took up arms and residence in Qinggūsabanner

companies from other groups who remained on the hunt, but not

the attack, in their native villages. Administrative space reflected

these differences during the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries.

The mid-SAH settlements were stripped by direct recruitment and

transfer of New Manchus while those of the lower SAH persisted

in place under traditional clan organizations subject to periodic super-

vision.^3 Modern scholars have characterized exchange relations with

this latter group as“rewarding pelt tribute with goods.”Such“tribute

relations”became an increasingly commercialized trade of pelts for

the textile products overseen by authorities at Ilan Hala in the

Qianlong period.^4

Nevertheless, borderland Manchu identity remainedfluid in practice

because it was based on a regional venery experience that permitted

the dynasty to draft and demobilize indigenous hunters. Units like Hei-

longjiang’s“Hunting Eight Banners”(Bu-te-ha baqi), composed mainly

of Solon-Ewenki, Dagur, Orochen, and Bargut, were training reserves. As

soldiers they could be relieved of their regular pelt tribute to grow grain,

but authorities recognized hunting as the prerequisite skill for all elite

banner troops. A 1732 edict offers a concise rationale for the state’s

venery construction of its soldiers:“it has been heard that the able-bodied

men of Butha Ula have multiplied to two or three thousand. Since all hunt

for a living, they are inured to toil and hardship...select 1 , 000 of those in

their prime as soldiers.”Foraging ability enabled hunters in Heilongjiang

and Jilin to be deployed in strategic, unarable, territory such as Hulun

Buir.^5

Embedded in regional ecological conditions through foraging,

indigenous peoples were among the resources mostfiercely contested

during the Romanov-Qing conflict over the SAH river basin in the latter

half of the seventeenth century. This imperialfight for space, pelts, and

people accelerated the dynasty’s formation of a borderland Manchu

64 Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain
Free download pdf