60 NaTIoNal SCIENCE TEaChERS aSSoCIaTIoN
Chapter 3 The Science Curriculum and Classroom Instruction
Table 3.4
Creating Learning Experiences
Research on How Students
Learn (Bransford, Brown,
and Cocking 1999, 2000)
Curricular Problem
Instructional Problem
Solution
Students come to
classrooms with
preconceptions about
how the world works.
Identify potential
misconceptions
Teach for
conceptual change
Instructional
model
Competence in an area
of inquiry includes (a)
a deep foundation of
factual knowledge, (b)
understanding facts and
ideas in the context of a
conceptual framework,
and (c) organizing
knowledge in ways that
facilitate retrieval and
application.
Incorporate both
factual knowledge
and a conceptual
framework
Establish major
concepts, introduce
knowledge, and
apply knowledge to
new situations
Design
curriculum
based
on major
scientific
concepts
and provide
experiences
to learn
factual
knowledge
and apply
it to new
situations
Students can learn
strategies that help them
monitor their progress in
problem solving.
Provide
opportunities
to introduce
and emphasize
students’
metacognitive
strategies
Teaching strategies
of inquiry
Emphasize
inquiry
abilities
The National Research Council report How People Learn (Bransford, Brown,
and Cocking 2000) supports the contention that the curriculum materials used in
most classrooms are far from demanding and coherent. Instead, “many models
of curriculum design seem to produce knowledge and skills that are discon-
nected rather than organized into coherent wholes” (Bransford, Brown, and
Cocking 2000, p. 138). In the science curriculum in particular, “existing curricula
tend to overemphasize facts and underemphasize ‘doing science’ to explore and
test big ideas” (Bransford, Brown, and Cocking 2000, p. 137).
The final challenge in answering the first question requires curriculum and
instruction that are rigorous, focused, and coherent. Rigor means centering on
the content, particularly the conceptual structure of science disciplines. Focus
refers to the depth of treatment of the content. Coherence refers to the connections
among science concepts and inquiry abilities in both horizontal and vertical
dimensions of the curriculum.
Copyright © 2010 NSTA. All rights reserved. For more information, go to http://www.nsta.org/permissions.