Mothers and Children. Jewish Family Life in Medieval Europe - Elisheva Baumgarten

(Rick Simeone) #1

Low Countries, 1300–1550(Chicago and London, 1998), 98–100; Henri Bresc, “Europe: Town
and Country,” in History of the Family, eds. André Burguière, Christiane Klapisch-Zuber, Mar-
tine Segalen, and Françoise Zonabend (Cambridge, Mass., 1996), 461–66. Bresc’s comparison of
Jewish and Christian societies is problematic because he compares Geniza society in Egypt and
medieval European cities.



  1. Grossman, Pious and Rebellious,63–87; idem, “Background to Family Ordinances—R.
    Gershom Me’or haGolah,” in Jewish History. Essays in Honor of Chimen Abramsky, eds. Ada Rap-
    paport-Albert and Steven J. Zipperstein (London, 1988), 3–23; Zeev Falk, Jewish Matrimonial
    Law, 86–112.

  2. Grossman discusses the importance of lineage at length in his Sages of Ashkenaz, 400–411,
    but he only hints at family sizes, 8, n. 32.

  3. Kenneth R. Stow, “The Jewish Family in the Rhineland in the High Middle Ages: Form
    and Function.” American Historical Review92(1987): 1085–1090.

  4. There is a need for further research concerning these networks. Irving A. Agus, Urban Civ-
    ilization in Pre-Crusade Europe: A Study of Organized Town-Life in Northwestern Europe during
    the Tenth and Eleventh Centuries based on the Responsa Literature(New York, 1965), 256–309;
    idem, The Heroic Age of Franco-German Jewry(New York, 1969), 101–44 is one of the few schol-
    ars to discuss these issues to date.

  5. Grossman, Sages of Ashkenaz, 400–412.

  6. A comparison with the data Goitein collected about Jewish society in medieval Fustat re-
    veals that although families often lived in shared courtyards, each conjugal unit was independent
    financially: Goitein, A Mediterranean Society(Berkeley, 1978), 2:188; 3;130; 231; 291.


Notes to Chapter 1


  1. A Mishnaic term for a miscarriage. For example: Niddah, 3:4.
    2.For example, the summary of previous research in Cohen, “Be Fertile.” Cohen surveys the in-
    tellectual history of the biblical commandment “Be fruitful and multiply,” but does not examine its
    social contexts. For further discussion of Cohen’s book, see p. 25.

  2. Ibid., and Ron Barkai, A History of Jewish Gynecological Texts in the Middle Ages(Leiden,
    Boston, and Köln, 1998) have described at length the place of birth in intellectual traditions. Al-
    though much has been written on the social aspects of birth in Christian society, nothing has been
    written on these aspects in medieval Jewish society.

  3. I am borrowing this formulation from Gail McMurray Gibson, “Scene and Obscene: See-
    ing and Performing Late Medieval Childbirth,” Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies
    29(1999): 7–24, esp. 9–11.

  4. Sherry Ortner, “Is Female to Male Like Nature Is to Culture?” in Making Gender(Prince-
    ton, 1996), 21–42; Helen Callaway, “The Most Essentially Female Function of All: Giving Birth,”
    in Defining Females. The Nature of Women in Society, ed. Shirley Ardener (Oxford and Provi-
    dence, 1993), 146–67.

  5. Shah·ar, The Fourth Estate, 98–106. Silvana Vecchio, “The Good Wife,” in A History of
    Women in the West, ed. Christiane Klapisch-Zuber (London and Cambridge, Mass., 1992), 2:106–
    107; Berkvam, Enfance et maternité, 77. Although men also became fathers and were expected to
    marry, they were primarily educated to study Torah and acquire a profession. We should note the
    difference between being educated to be a wife and being educated to be a mother. The extent to
    which the distinctions discerned by Vecchio apply to contemporaneous Jewish culture have only
    recently been examined. See Grossman, Pious and Rebellious, 216–29.

  6. MS Oxford Bodl., Opp. 170, (1205), fol. 104 b–c. This manuscript contains a commentary
    on piyutimmentioning many thirteenth-century scholars from northern France.

  7. Ibid., fol. 105 c–d. For the piyut, see: Mah·zor le-Vamim nora’im, ed. Daniel Goldschmidt


198 NOTES TO CHAPTER 1
Free download pdf