India\'s Israel Policy - P. R. Kumaraswamy

(vip2019) #1

  • Since the visit of Israeli Minister Yigal Allon to attend an interna-
    tional conference in 1965, this was perhaps the fi rst visit to India by
    an important Israeli functionary.

  • The visit was due to the Israeli desire to explore the possibilities of
    a improvement in relations in the wake of po liti cal changes in both
    countries.^84

  • Conceding that India should have established full relations soon
    after its recognition in September 1950, Desai expressed his inabil-
    ity to modify the situation unless Israel withdrew from the occu-
    pied territories.^85

  • The visit was not made public because of its explosive nature, and
    in the words of Dayan, “If the news of my visit to him [Desai] now
    were to be published, he said, he [Desai] would be out of offi ce.”^86

  • The INC government, which came to power in January 1980,
    claimed there were no offi cial rec ords on the substance of the
    meeting.^87

  • Dayan was unable to achieve his basic objective, namely, an im-
    provement in Indo- Israeli relations. Some suggested that Dayan’s
    primary goal was “to upgrade the Israeli Consulate in Bombay to a
    Consulate- General and further to shift it to Delhi.”^88 Even this did
    not happen.

  • A sensitive foreign- policy matter became a domestic po liti cal battle
    when Prime Minister Indira Gandhi disclosed Dayan’s visit during
    an election rally on May 10, 1980. There followed a heated debate
    both inside and outside the parliament.^89 Foreign Minister Rao,
    however, maintained that the visit was fi rst disclosed by a New
    York newspaper, News and Cine India, on April 26, 1979, and was
    picked up and repeated by various other media outlets, including
    Israel Radio.^90

  • The government of Indira Gandhi maintained that Dayan’s visit
    had “damaged India’s image” and “lowered India’s prestige” in the
    Arab world.^91

  • The visit was apparently or ga nized by the Israeli businessman
    Shoul Isenberg.^92 Around the same time, he initiated military ties
    between Israel and China, long before normalization of relations
    between the two countries.^93


The incognito visit was not entirely futile, as there were some notice-
able changes in India’s overall policy. Without disclosing Dayan’s visit,


220 the years of hardened hostility, 1964–1984
Free download pdf