A History of Ancient Near Eastern Law

(Romina) #1

558 


In addition, the culprit will “compensate the life” (nap“àte umalla),
that is, will pay a sum equal to the value of the aborted fetus (MAL
A 50:65–69). If the victim is a prostitute, the attacker receives a tal-
ionic punishment of “blow for blow” (mi¢ßìkî mi¢ßì) and pays com-
pensation for the loss of the fetus (MAL A 52). A fine is the penalty
for a miscarriage caused to a woman who, for physiological reasons,
cannot raise the children she bears (MAL A 51). If the injury makes
a woman who has not borne sons sterile, it is a serious offense car-
rying the death penalty (MAL A 50:74–79). Causing a miscarriage
is thus defined as an injury inflicted on a pregnant woman and not
as an assault on the life of the fetus, which is perceived as part of
the mother’s property and an item of the father’s property.

8.6 Self-inflicted Abortion


According to MAL A 53, a woman convicted of this offense is con-
demned to impalement and denied burial. These punishments are
applicable post mortem if the culprit dies as a result of the abor-
tion.^143 It is a punishable offense not to report the crime.

8.7 Homicide


8.7.1 The punishment for murder is left to the discretion of the
head of the victim’s family: he may choose between death or com-
position, comprising the culprit’s property or, if he is insolvent, a
son or daughter (MAL A 10). An undivided heir who commits the
same offense is also handed over to the avenger of blood, who may
demand his death or his inheritance share (MAL B 2). In the lat-
ter case, either the coheirs agreed to divide the estate so as to sep-
arate offthe culprit’s share, or they accepted the stranger as a joint
owner.^144

8.7.2 Unpremeditated homicide is envisaged in the case of causing
a miscarriage. If the injury results in the death of the pregnant
woman, the culprit suffers the death penalty and must, in addition,
pay the victim’s husband the value of the fetus (MAL A 50:70–73).

(^143) The law could also be understood as covering both an attempted abortion (ll.
92–97) and a successful abortion (ll. 98–101): Roth, Law Collections.. ., 174, 193,
n. 30.
(^144) Cardascia, Lois.. ., 265.
WESTBROOK_f13–521-563 8/27/03 12:27 PM Page 558

Free download pdf