China\'s Quest. The History of the Foreign Relations of the People\'s Republic of China - John Garver

1

1 }

The Fateful Embrace of Communism

and Its Consequence

State Formation and Foreign Policy

The premise of this book is that China in 1949 adopted a deeply dysfunctional
political-economic model from the USSR and that this fact has deeply influ-
enced the foreign relations of the People’s Republic of China ever since. After
trying for thirty years to make the Soviet economic model of comprehen-
sive economic planning work well, China’s leaders incrementally abandoned
that model, starting in 1978. Over the next three-plus decades, China’s lead-
ers managed with amazing success the transition from a planned command
economy to a globalized market economy—and did this while raising hun-
dreds of millions of Chinese to midlevels of prosperity, transforming China
into one of the leading economies in the world, and freeing the Chinese
people from the myriad daily oppressions that were part and parcel of Mao’s
utopian quest. But while abandoning the economic half of the Soviet model,
China retained the political half. That political half was profoundly modified
as China transited from a planned to a market economy, but the core aspect
remained unchanged: a Leninist state in which a centralized and disciplined
party maintains perpetual control over the state while dictatorially repressing
autonomous political activity. The ways in which China’s Leninist party, the
Chinese Communist Party (CCP), and that party’s state, the People’s Republic
of China (PRC), relate to Chinese society shifted profoundly with the transi-
tion from a planned to a market economy. But the key mechanisms of party
control over the state, tracing back to the USSR in the 1920s and 1930s, remain
in place.^1 This has had profound implications for the legitimacy of the CCP
party state and for PRC relations with liberal democratic powers.
It is too early to say whether China will be able to make the remaining
Leninist political half of its Soviet heritage work well over the long run. The
CCP itself argues, plausibly, that since 1978 it has ruled pretty well and that its