12 SPRING 2020 MOVIEMAKER.COM
PREPARING
MY DINNER WITH ANDRÉ
Exclusive excerpt from This is Not My Memoir
BY ANDRÉ GREGORY AND TODD LONDON
EXCLUSIVE BOOK EXCERPT
LEFT: COURTESY OF FARRAR, STRAUS AND GIROUX; RIGHT: PHOTOGRAPH COURTESY OF PHOTOFEST
(Editor’s Note: My Dinner with André famously consists almost solely of a philosophical conversation over dinner between two longtime
friends and unknowns at the time: film and theater actor Wallace Shawn and actor and theater director André Gregory. Since its premiere
at the 1981 Telluride Film Festival, Shawn and Gregory have maintained that the versions of themselves in the film are strictly fictional,
although elements of their actual experiences and personal lives do make their way into their winding conversation. This exclusive
excerpt from Gregory’s forthcoming memoir, This Is Not My Memoir, recounts how famed French director Louis Malle joined on as
director, the endless hours of excruciating memorization Gregory endured, and the nigh impossible path to funding.)
ALLY CALLED ME and
said something like, “Listen,
I know what you’re going
through, and when I’m
your age I don’t want to
go through it myself. So in order for me to
prevent that, what do you think of the two
of us sitting together, you telling me your
stories, and out of that we might create
a talking heads TV show?” Not an earth-
shattering idea, but okay. Sure, why not?
And so we sat in a tiny classroom in
New York and talked. We recorded these
talks on tape. We began each day with
a story of mine. They weren’t all about
eating sand in the Sahara with a Buddhist
monk or being buried alive. Just stories.
About anything at all.
The stories would become conversation.
About anything at all.
We talked and talked. It was fun. It
was fun to be with Wally. It was a relief to
do something. And it was great not to be
alone. It went on this way for months. We
discussed almost everything.
WALLY TOOK THE COUNTLESS HOURS
of transcript and reduced it to a script. Even
so, Wally had written one of the longest
screenplays ever, with a role for André
that would become, I believe, the longest
speaking role in the history of film.
AS IF ANYONE IN THE WORLD would
want to direct a movie written by and
starring two unknowns, who sit at a table
for hours and do nothing but talk, we set
out to determine the perfect director for
My Dinner with André (a title so mundane
that I wanted to change it). Bergman
would be good, we thought, if only he had
a sense of humor. Richard Avedon might
be interesting, if only he were a director
and not a photographer. Eric Rohmer? Not
profound enough. We considered nearly
every movie director alive to shoot our
“masterpiece.” But even if someone would
agree to direct this lunatic project, who in
the world would want to see it, except for a
handful of friends and loved ones?
ONE DAY MY FRIEND Diana Michener
came over for tea. Diana, a fine
photographer, told me she was shooting
a series on death. I said something like:
“Wanna see death? I can show you death.”
I put on a suit Pierre Cardin had given me
when Alice opened at his Paris theater.
I always thought it made me look like
a vampire. “Oh my god,” she said. “You do
look like death. May I shoot you in that
suit?” “Sure. Why not?”
We shot the pictures in her studio.
We planned to go to dinner afterward,
and Wally, also a good friend of hers,
came by to pick us up. He carried our
“masterpiece” under his arm. An admirer
of Wally’s plays, Diana asked to read the
screenplay. “Sure. Why not?”
A COUPLE NIGHTS LATER I got a call
from a man with an odd French accent.
He claimed to be Louis Malle. He had just
finished our script and sounded as if he were
in tears. “If you don’t want me to direct it,”
he said, “I would love to produce it. The only
thing... I beg you... no flashbacks. It must
W