Total
£35,561
0 5000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 40,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
£3585
£16 0 5
£0
£3585 £0
£15 0 0
£28,439 £1797 £174 0
Total
£ 30,416
Value
£
0 year 1 year 2 years 3 years
£32,764
£ 27,5 5 0
TeslaModel 3
TeslaModelS
£23,726
76 August 2020 whatcar.com
thenyou’dlosetheaddedsecurity
ofhavingsomewarrantyleft.
Whennew,bothmodelscome
withafour-year/50,000-mile
warranty;thebatteryhaseight
years’coverwithnomileagelimit.
Tesladoesn’tdotrimlevels
assuchandhasneveroffered
alongoptionslist.Asidefrom
exteriorandinteriorcolours,our
contendersaresimilarlyequipped.
Autopilot,Tesla’sadaptivecruise
controlandsteeringassistance
packageformotorwayuse,is
standardontheModel3.These
featureswereoptionalonthe
ModelSatthetime,aspartofan
EnhancedAutopilotpackthat
alsoallowedthecartoparkitself,
changelanesautonomouslyon
themotorwayandbesummoned
viaasmartphoneatverylow
speeds.It’sworthlookingfora
ModelSthathasthispackfitted.
Togetallofthesefunctionson
theModel3,you’llneedtopay
£5800toaddFullSelf-Driving
Capability.Whenlegislation
allows,thiswillalsoenablethe
cartorecognisestopsignsand
redtrafficlightsandbringyou
toastandstillaccordingly,as
well as navigating its way around
cities autonomously.
For a fee, you can retrospectively
add Full Self-Driving Capability on
thefloorinbothcarsisraised
toaccommodatethebigbattery
packthatsitsunderneath.This
meanstheseatingpositionfeelsa
tadunnatural,withyourfeetand
kneeshigherthantheywouldbe
inaBMW 3 Series,forexample,but
yousoongetusedtoit.
Bothmodelshavemassesof
luggagespace.Wesqueezedatotal
of 10 carry-onsuitcasesintothe
Model 3 and 11 intheModelS.
Forcomparison,the 3 Seriescan
takejustseven.Tesla’strickis
providingnotonebuttwoboots:a
bigonewhereyou’dexpectitand
asmallerstorageareaunderthe
bonnet.Bothcarshaverearseats
thatfolddownforextraspace,too.
BUYINGANDOWNING
Costs,equipment,reliability,
safetyandsecurity
Alow-mileage, 2018 ModelS75D
willsetyoubackaround£56,000–
roughly£500lessthanyou’d
payforabrandnewModel 3
Performance.However,thelatter
ispredictedtoholdonitsvalue
muchbetter,helpingtocutcosts
inthelongterm.
Yes, you could go for an older
Model S with more miles on the
clock for less money (Tesla started
building them back in 2012), but
TESLAMODEL 3
TESLAMODELS
Agile,accuratehandlingis matchedbya well-controlled,if rm,ridein theModel 3
HeavierModelS can’tkeepupona twistyroadbutis morecomfortablearoundtown
BEST T0
DRIVE
CARSPICTURED
RESALEVALUEBYYEAR
THREE-YEARCOST
DepreciationInsuranceServicingRoadtax
Electricity(RealRange)
TeslaModel 3 TeslaModelS
WHATTHEYWILLCOST
EQUIPMENT
NEW USED
All prices correct at time of testing
Tesla Model 3 Performance with Full Self-Driving
Capability (£5800) and red multi-coat paint (£1900)
Tesla Model S 75D with silver metallic paint (£950) and
white premium interior (£3100)
Tesla Model 3
List price £56,490
Target Price £56,490
PCP nance £939 per month*
Tesla Model S
Used price £56,000
(2018/68-plate)
PCP nance £1116 per month*
Alloy wheel size 19in
Climate control
Adaptive cruise/steer assist
Infotainment screen size 15in
Apple CarPlay/Android Auto /
Panoramic roof
Synthetic leather seats
Adjustable lumbar support
Self-parking function £5800*
Parking sensors front/rear /
Heated front/rear seats /
Alloy wheel size 19in
Climate control
Adaptive cruise control/steer assist Opt
Infotainment screen size 17in
Apple CarPlay/Android Auto /
Panoramic roof
Synthetic leather seats
Adjustable lumbar support
Self-parking function Opt
Parking sensors front/rear /
Heated front/rear seats /Opt
Both cars have useful front boots that can hold a couple of bags or charging cables
Standard Unavailable Opt: Optional when new *Part of Full Self-Driving Capability package
- Three-year term, £5000 customer deposit, 10,000 miles per year
NEW VS USED