Your essay should not explain whether you agree with [the author’s] claims, but rather
explain how the author builds an argument to persuade [his/her] audience.
In the essay, you will:
- carefully read a text
- understand how an author appeals to a reader’s logic, emotions, or morals
- write a logical analysis of an argument
- explain how style choices can affect an author’s persuasiveness
In the essay, you will NOT:
- give your opinion about a text
- memorize examples from history or literature
- have previous experience with the text
Two graders will read and score the essay on a 1–4 scale in three different categories: Reading, Analysis,
and Writing.
4 = Advanced
3 = Proficient
2 = Partial
1 = Inadequate
The scores will be determined using the following rubric. There is a lot of information here. You don’t
need to memorize this, but it may help you understand the scoring a little more. We’ll go through the first
two tasks in this chapter, followed by the third task—Writing—in Chapter 19.
Essay Scoring
Reading, Analysis, and
Writing scores will be
combined for a total score
of 3–12. (Each category
will receive a total score
of 2–8, which is found
by adding the individual
1–4 scores from your two
readers.) Each task
(Reading, Analysis, and
Writing) is scored
individually, so a high
score in one does
not guarantee a high
score in another.