run, thanks to the lack of barriers to entry, it would be
impossible to maintain such a monopoly.
- a.False. As illustrated in panel (b) of Figure 67.4, a monop-
olistically competitive firm sells its output at a price that
exceeds marginal cost—unlike a perfectly competitive
firm, which sells at a price equal to marginal cost. Not
only does a monopolistically competitive firm maximize
profit by charging more than marginal cost, but in long-
run equilibrium, a price equal to marginal cost would be
below average total cost and cause the firm to incur a
loss.
b.True. Firms in a monopolistically competitive industry
could achieve higher profit (monopoly profit) if they all
joined together as a single firm with a single product.
Because each of the smaller firms possesses excess capaci-
ty, a single firm producing a larger quantity would have a
lower average total cost. The effect on consumers, howev-
er, is ambiguous. They would experience less choice. But
if consolidation substantially reduced industry-wide aver-
age total cost and increases industry-wide output, con-
sumers could experience lower prices with the monopoly.
c.True. Fads and fashions are promulgated by advertising
and a desire for product differentiation, which are com-
mon in oligopolies and monopolistically competitive
industries, but not in monopolies or perfectly competitive
industries.
Tackle the Test:
Multiple-Choice Questions - b
- e
- b
- b
- e
Tackle the Test:
Free-Response Questions
MC ATC
Quantity
Price,
cost,
marginal
revenue
PMC = ATCMC
MCMC
QMC
MRMC DMC
Minimum-cost output
Excess capacity
it. Because it could gain market share by doing so,
refusing to do so supports the conclusion that there is
tacit collusion.
Tackle the Test:
Multiple-Choice Questions
- d
- d
- c
- e
- a
Tackle the Test:
Free-Response Questions
- a.A large number of firms: having more firms means there
is less incentive for any firm to behave cooperatively.
b.Complex products/pricing schemes: keeping track of
adherence to an agreement is more difficult.
c.Differences in interests: firms often have different views
of their own interests and of what a fair agreement would
entail.
d.Bargaining power of buyers: firms are less able to raise
prices for buyers with significant bargaining power, which
can result from size or access to many options.
Module 67
Check Your Understanding
- a.An increase in fixed cost shifts the average total cost
curve upward. In the short run, firms incur losses
because price is below average total cost. In the long run,
some firms will exit the industry, resulting in a rightward
shift of the demand curves for those firms that remain,
since each firm now serves a larger share of the market.
Long-run equilibrium is reestablished when the demand
curve for each remaining firm has shifted rightward to
the point where it is tangent to the firm’s new, higher
average total cost curve. At this point each firm’s price
just equals its average total cost, and each firm makes
zero profit.
b.A decrease in marginal cost shifts the average total cost
curve and the marginal cost curve downward. In the
short run, firms earn positive economic profit. In the
long run new entrants are attracted into the industry by
the profit. This results in a leftward shift of each existing
firm’s demand curve because each firm now has a small-
er share of the market. Long-run equilibrium is reestab-
lished when each firm’s demand curve has shifted left-
ward to the point where it is tangent to the new, lower
average total cost curve. At this point each firm’s price
just equals average total cost, and each firm makes zero
profit. - If all the existing firms in the industry joined together to
create a monopoly, they could achieve positive economic
profit in the short run. But this would induce new firms
to create new, differentiated products and then enter the
industry and capture some of the profit. So, in the long
S-42 SOLUTIONS TO AP REVIEW QUESTIONS