W.EUGENESMITHUptoandincludingtheinstantofexposure,thephotographerisworkinginanundeniably
subjectivewayByhischoiceoftechnicalapproach(whichisatoolofemotionalcontrol),byhisselectionofthesubjectmattertobeheldwithintheconfinesofhisnegativearea.andbyhisdecisionastotheexact,climacticinstant ofexposure,heisblendingthevariablesofinterpretationintoanemotionalwholeTheworkingmethodofthesecondphotographerwasacomplexprocessofexplorationandselection.Heexaminedalloftheobjectsbeforehiscam-era—thebuilding,itscontentsanditssurroundings—
andexploredthemean-ingsthatmightbeattachedtothem.Duringthisperiodofobservation,manypotentialpicturesbeckoned—
thetrees,thearcade,thewoman,there-flections.Thenoneidea—theparadoxoflifewithinasterileskyscraper—
seemedricherandmorecompellingthananyother.Whateverwasirrele-vantordistractingheexcluded.Whatremainedwascarefullypositionedinhisviewfinder
sothatitsimportancewasevident.Hetunedthemixoftheseelements,likeamusicianseekingachordwhosenotesblendperfectly.Andwhenhewassurethateverypartwouldfittogetherandcontributetothewhole,hetookthepicture.Thisanalyticalapproachisnotuniquetophotography,butitisapplicable.Photographyis
aspecialartinthattheexplorationandselectionmustbedoneeitherinadvanceofpicturetaking,beforetheshutteristripped,oraf-terwardinthedarkroom.Itisasthoughacomposerweretoconceiveasymphonycompletefrombeginningtoend,pushabutton,andpresto!Anor-chestrawouldplaythemusic.Theveryeasewithwhichfilmcangenerateanentirepicturehindersmanyphotographersfromdevelopingtheirskills.Theymaybemisledintobelievingthatalltheyhavetodotoguaranteeatleastonegoodpictureistakeagreatnumberofshotsofasubject,andtheyconcentrateontheactofimage-recordingratherthanontheprocessofpic-turecreation.Inmanycases,alargenumberofshotsareadvisable,butquantityalonecannotassuresuccess.Itisthecarefullythought-outpho-tographthatcommunicatesitsmaker'smessage.Inanalyzingapicture,theskillfulphotographerperformsthreedifferentsortsofexploration.Heexamineshisfeelingsandthoughtsaboutthesub-ject—inshort,itsmeaningtohim.Heexaminesallthevisualattributesofthescene,seekingthosethatwillbestconveyhissenseofthemeaning.Andheconsidersvariouswaysinwhichthechosenvisualelementscanbearrangedinthepicture,sothatthemeaningcanbeefficientlygrasped.Inpractice,thesethreesortsofexplorationgoonsimultaneously,eachinfluencingtheothers.Noticingaparticularshapemightsuggestanewmeaningandtheneedforacertaindesign.Theexplorationsmaybequickorevenintuitive;somephotographersspeakofinstantaneous"recognition' ofwhattoshootandhowtoshootit.Conversely,manyfinephotographersspendagreatdealoftimecontemplatingtheirsubjectsandadjustingthetiniestdetails.Breakingupthecreativeprocessintothreeareasofexplorationandselectionisonlytheinitialstep,ofcourse.Eacharea—meaning,
visualcharacteristics,arrangement—isitselfsubjecttoadditionalexplorationandselection.Meaning,forexample,dependsonthememories,cravings,