Mathematical Tools for Physics - Department of Physics - University

(nextflipdebug2) #1
11—Numerical Analysis 284

y


x


Do this in two dimensions, fitting the given data to a straight line, and to describe the line I’ll

use vector notation, where the line is~u+α~vand the parameterαvaries over the reals. First I need


to answer the simple question: what is the distance from a point to a line? The perpendicular distance


from~wto this line requires that


d^2 =


(

~w−~u−α~v


) 2

be a minimum. Differentiate this with respect toαand you have


(~w−~u−α~v


)

.

(

−~v


)

= 0 implying αv^2 =


(

~w−~u


)

.~v


For this value ofαwhat isd^2?


d^2 =


(

~w−~u


) 2

+α^2 v^2 − 2 α~v.


(

~w−~u


)

=

(

~w−~u


) 2


1

v^2


[

(~w−~u).~v


] 2 (11.54)


Is this plausible? (1) It’s independent of the size of~v, depending on its direction only. (2) It depends


on only thedifferencevector between~wand~u, not on any other aspect of the vectors. (3) If I add any


multiple of~vto~u, the result is unchanged. See problem11.37. Also,can you find an easier way to get


the result?Perhaps one that simply requires some geometric insight?


The data that I’m trying to fit will be described by a set of vectors ~wi, and the sum of the


distances squared to the line is


D^2 =


∑N

1

(

~wi−~u


) 2


∑N

1

1

v^2


[

(~wi−~u).~v


] 2

Now to minimize this among all~uand~v I’ll first take advantage of some of the observations from the


preceding paragraph. Because the magnitude of~vdoes not matter, I’ll make it a unit vector.


D^2 =


∑(

~wi−~u


) 2


∑[

(~wi−~u).vˆ


] 2

(11.55)


Now to figure out~u: Note that I expect the best fit line to go somewhere through the middle of the


set of data points, so move the origin to the “center of mass” of the points.


~wmean=



~wi/N and let ~wi′=~wi−~wmean and ~u′=~u−~wmean


then the sum



~wi′= 0and


D^2 =



w′i^2 +Nu′^2 −



(~wi′.vˆ)^2 −N(~u′.ˆv)^2 (11.56)


This depends on four variables,u′x,u′y,vxandvy. If I have to do derivatives with respect to all of them,


so be it, but maybe some geometric insight will simplify the calculation. I can still add any multiple ofˆv

Free download pdf