his whole system, was also condemned by a provincial Synod of Sens, and afterwards by Pope
Honorius III. in 1225, who characterized it as a book "teeming with the vermin of heretical
depravity," and ordered all copies to be burned. But, fortunately, a few copies survived for the study
of later ages.
§ 124. The Eucharistic Controversies. Literature.
The general Lit. on the history of the doctrine of the Eucharist, see in vol. I., § 55, p. 472, and II.
241.
Add the following Roman Catholic works on the general Subject: Card. Jo. de Lugo (d. 1660):
Tractatus de venerabili Eucharistiae Sacramento, in Migne’s "Cursus Theol. Completus," XXIII.
Card. Wiseman: Lectures on the Real Presence. Lond., 1836 and l842. Oswald: Die dogmat.
Lehre von den heil. Sacramenten der katholischen Kirche. Münster, 3rd ed., 1870, vol. I.
375–427.
On the Protestant side: T. K. Meier: Versuch einer Gesch. der Transsubstantiationslehre. Heilbronn,
- Ebrard: Das Dogma v. heil. Abendmahl und seine Gesch. Frankf. a. M., 1845 and ’46, 2
vols. Steitz: Arts. on Radbert, Ratramnus, and Transubstantiation in Herzog. Schaff:
Transubstantiation in "Rel. Encycl." III. 2385.
Special Lit. on the eucharistic controversies in the ninth and eleventh centuries.
I. Controversy between Ratramnus and Paschasius Radbertus.
(1) Paschasius Radbertus: Liber de Corpore et Sanguine Domini, dedicated to Marinus, abbot of
New Corbie, 831, second ed., 844, presented to Charles the Bald; first genuine ed. by Nic.
Mameranus, Colon. 1550; best ed. by Martene and Durand in "Veter. Script. et Monum.
amplissima Collectio," IX. 367.—Comm. in Matth. (26:26); Epistola ad Fridegardum, and
treatise De Partu Virginis. See S. Pasch. Radb.: Opera omnia in Tom. 120 of Migne’s "Patrol.
Lat.," Par. 1852.
Haimo: Tract. de Corp. et Sang. Dom. (a fragment of a Com. on 1 Cor.), in D’Achery, "Spicil." I.
42, and in Migne, "P. L.," Tom. 118, col. 815–817. Hincmar: Ep. ad Carol. Calv. de cavendis
vitiis et virtutibus exercendis, c. 9. In Migne, T. 125, col. 915 sqq.
(2) Ratramnus: De Corpore et Sanguine Domini liber ad Carolum Calvum Reg. Colon., 1532 (under
the name of Bertram), often publ. by Reformed divines in the original and in translations (from
1532 to 1717 at Zürich, Geneva, London, Oxford, Amsterdam), and by Jac. Boileau, Par., 1712,
with a vindication of the catholic orthodoxy of Ratramnus. See Ratramni Opera in Migne," P.
L.," Tom. 121, col. 10–346.
Rabanus Maurus: Poenitentiale, cap. 33. Migne," P. L." Tom. 110, col. 492, 493. Walafrid Strabo:
De Rebus Eccls., c. 16, 17. See extracts in Gieseler, II. 80–82.
(3) Discussions of historians: Natalis Alexander, H. Eccl. IX. and X., Dissert. X. and XIII. Neander,
IV. 458–475, Germ. ed., or III. 495–501, Engl. transl., Bost. ed. Gieseler, II. 79–84, N. Y. ed.
Baur: Vorlesungen über Dogmengesch. II. 161–175.
II. Controversy between Berengar and Lanfranc.
(1) LANFRANCUS: De Eucharistiae Sacramento contra Berengarium lib., Basil,. 1528, often publ.,
also in "Bibl. PP. Lugd.," XVIII. 763, and in Migne," Patrol. Lat.," Tom. 150 (1854), col.
407–442.