property law

Vol

August 2
due to th

IPR2014

In this de
informati
itself. Un
the relief
Here, Pet
the prior
declaratio
exclusive
Declarati
three-lev
incorpora
Petitione

The Boar
of citatio
made in t
petitions
Argumen
pursuant

lumino

2 8, 2014 – In

e Petitioner’

-00491 – Fid

ecision deny

ion containe

nder 37 C.F.R

f requested, i

titioner subm

art teaches o

on containin

ely to a 1,00

ion as Exhib

vel incorpora

ating the cla

r impermiss

rd ruled that

ons to the ref

the ... Decla

.” The Board

nts made in a

to 37 C.F.R

us Dec

n a decision o

’s excessive

delity Nation

ing institutio

ed in a suppo

R. § 42.22(a

including a d

mitted a claim

or suggests e

ng 1,278 para

3 page, sing

bit A.” The c

ation techniq

im chart, and

ibly sought t

the “petition

ferences them

aration into t

d refused to

a supporting

R. § 42.6(a)( 3

claratio

IPR

By Chris

of interest, th

reliance on

nal Informat

on of an inte

orting declara

a)(2) a petitio

detailed expl

m-by-claim

each elemen

agraphs. In t

le-spaced, cl

claim chart th

que – the peti

d the claim c

to greatly ex

n’s extensiv

mselves amo

the Petition,

consider the

g document m

3 ).

on Lead

R Petitio

topher L. M

he PTAB de

a voluminou

tion Services

er partes rev

ation, but no

on must incl

lanation of th

analysis for

t of the claim

those paragra

laim chart in

hen cites to t

ition incorpo

chart incorpo

xpand its arg

e reliance on

ounts to an in

thereby circ

e information

may not be in

ds to P

on

McKee

enied institut

us supporting

s, Inc. v. Dat

iew, the Boa

ot sufficientl

lude a “full s

he significan

nine ground

m. Petitioner

aphs, the dec

n landscape f

the reference

orating the d

orating from

guments in su

n citations to

ncorporation

cumventing t

n found only

ncorporated

TAB D

tion of inter

g declaration

tatreasury C

ard refused t

ly presented

statement of

nce of the ev

ds of unpaten

r chiefly cite

clarant point

format appe

es themselve

declaration, t

m the referen

upport of the

o the ... Dec

n by referenc

the page lim

y in the decla

by referenc

Denial o

partes revie

n:

Corp. (Paper

to consider

in the petitio

fthe reasons

vidence....”

ntability, alle

es to a 287 p

ts “almost

nded to [the

es. Through

the declaratio

nces – the

e petition.

claration in li

ce of argume

mits that appl

aration.

e into a petit

of

ew

9)

on

for

eging

age

e]

this

on

ieu

ents

y to

tion,