Cities of God: The Religion of the Italian Communes 1125-1325

(Darren Dugan) #1

 264 BuoniCattolici


period, laypeople left benefactions to erect altars in honor of the Body of


Christ.^182


After the institution of the elevation, both men and women in communal


Italy cultivated a visual mysticism focused on the elevated Host.^183 The lay


practice of genuflecting instead of bowing at the elevation was partially moti-


vated by the desire to keep visual contact. Oringa Cristina had visions of


Christ before the altar at the time of the elevation, as did Giovanni Buono,


who often shed tears as he gazed at the Host.^184 Giovanni of Alverna saw


Christ become present at the altar during the Consecration or the Canon.^185


The elevation itself was a privileged time, a powerful time, for petition.


Donna Neze, the prioress of the Franciscan sisters at Empoli, prayed to Saint


Gerardo of Cagnoli for help in ending the factions that plagued her convent.


The saint spoke to her during the elevation and told her that the nuns should


kneel and say a Pater and an Ave, that the ‘‘King and Queen of heaven


might grant them peace.’’ They did as instructed, holding candles and wax


votive hearts. Peace was restored.^186 Not all encouraged visual contact.


When asked why his face was so radiant during the Canon, the Servite priest


Francesco Patrizzi chastised the inquirer. During the Consecration, the


priest was in Christ’s presence, as Moses was in God’s presence on Mount


Sinai. Moses had veiled his radiant face lest the Israelites see it, so the laity


should avert their eyes at the sacred moment and not look at the Host.^187


Francesco was in the minority.


Saint Francis of Assisi’s deathbed testament expressed the lay Eucharistic


piety of his age. He placed reverence for the Sacrament at the head of his


instructions to his followers: the Little Poor Man ordered them to provide


rich receptacles for the Blessed Sacrament. Francis returned time and again


to the Real Presence in his short letters and writings.^188 One senses in Francis


of Assisi’s typically lay concerns a rebuke of routinized clerical piety. The


visions and miracles of the communal saints reveal less veiled criticisms.


Jesus himself assured Margherita of Cortona, after one of her most fervent


Communions, that although her long thanksgivings after Mass might bother


the clerics, they delighted him.^189 Let Margherita express her feelings in her


own words, or rather in the words of Christ she recorded on another occa-


sion: ‘‘My daughter, I complain to you about the irreverence of priests who,


in such great number, handle me daily and yet neither love nor recognize


me. If they truly recognized me, they would know that nothing among all



  1. As at Bologna in San Giacomo Maggiore:Iscrizioni medievali bolognesi, 313 – 14 , nos. 14 – 15.

  2. Cf. Kieckhefer, ‘‘Holiness and the Culture,’’ 290.
    184 .Legenda Beatae Christianae, 63 ,p. 238 ;Processus... B. Joannis Boni, 3. 9. 240 ,p. 832.
    185 .Acta [B. Joannis Firmani sive Alvernae], 4. 36 ,p. 466 ;Acta Alia [B. Joannis Firmani], 3. 24 – 26 ,AS 36
    (Aug.ii), 474.

  3. Bartolomeo Albizzi,Legenda Sancti Gerardi, 7. 148 ,p. 443.

  4. Cristoforo of Parma,Legenda Beati Francisci, 9 ,p. 178.

  5. See citations in Maccarrone, ‘‘Cura animarum,’’ 157 – 59.

  6. Giunta Bevegnati,Legenda... Margaritae de Cortona, 2. 1 f, pp. 193 – 94.

Free download pdf