Cities of God: The Religion of the Italian Communes 1125-1325

(Darren Dugan) #1

 430 Epilogue


There is no reason to assume the man was himself a heretic, or even a


sympathizer.


By the 1290 s heresy hunting was on a collision course with lay piety. Saint


Pietro of Foligno got dragged before the Franciscan inquisitor of Assisi, who


grilled him on the Incarnation, Passion, Resurrection, and Ascension of


Christ, and then sent him off under detention to Spoleto. It was a sorry affair


in the eyes of Pietro’s biographer.^80 Already in the 1260 s, an inquisitor’s


suspicions about the orthodoxy of Giovanni Buono of Mantua brought his


canonization process to a halt and then ended it permanently.^81 Inquisitors


scrutinized the cults of long-dead communal saints. Perhaps they undertook


a systematic review of all such devotions.^82 Guido Da Loca of Brescia, a lay


penitent who had imitated the penances of John the Baptist, had long en-


joyed a popular cult, a tomb in the Brescia duomo, and a reputation for


miraculous healings. A posthumous inquest under the Dominican bishop of


Brescia, Bartolomeo of Braganze, condemned him of heresy. Familiars of


the inquisition broke open his tomb and burned his bones in the presence of


‘‘nearly forty thousand people.’’ When they were thrown into the fire, his


bones miraculously floated above the flames and remained unharmed. The


crowd began to cry, ‘‘Death to the bishop and the friars!’’ But the clerics


escaped harm, supposedly by producing the Blessed Sacrament and chasing


off the demons protecting the false saint’s relics. Such is the story told by


Filippo of Ferrara.^83 In any case, Saint Guido’s cult was suppressed. More


notorious still was the case of Saint Alberto of Villa d’Ogna, the wine porter


of Cremona. Saint Alberto worked miracles in Cremona at his tomb, at


Parma in San Pietro near Piazza Nuova, and at Reggio in the churches of


San Giorgio and San Giovanni Battista. At Parma, his devotees processed


through town with his relics, carrying crosses and banners and singing. The


offerings at his shrine amounted to £ 300 imp., sufficient to buy a house in


the contrada of Santo Stefano and open a hospital named in his honor.


Parish priests erected images of him in their churches, and people had his


image painted on porticoes and city walls. But Alberto was a drunkard, said


Fra Salimbene, and his devotees were a pack of wine guzzlers and silly


women.^84 Thank goodness a Franciscan inquisitor finally got around to sup-


pressing his cult.


No suppression of a cult equaled in notoriety that of Saint Armanno Pun-



  1. Giovanni Gorini,[Legenda de Vita et Obitu Beati Petri de Fulgineo], 2. 14 ,AS 31 (Jul.iv), 668 , and ibid.,
    9 b,Analecta Bollandiana 8 ( 1889 ): 365.

  2. Golinelli, ‘‘Dal santo,’’ 33 – 34.

  3. So suggests Wessley, ‘‘Thirteenth-Century Guglielmites,’’ 302 n. 68 , and Orioli,Venit Perfidus
    Heresiarcha, 80 – 81.

  4. Filippo of Ferrara,Liber de Introductione Loquendi, 2. 25 , in Bologna, Biblioteca Universitaria,ms 1552
    (xvcent., original ca. 1330 ), fols. 8 r–v, and the version edited by Creytens in ‘‘Le manuel de conversation,’’
    120 – 21 , from Vatican City, Biblioteca Vaticana,msPal. Lat. 960 , fol. 94 v.

  5. Does he by these terms simply mean laypeople? Salimbene,Cronica( 1279 ), 733 – 36 , Baird trans.,
    512 – 13. Alberto’s cult is also described inChronicon Parmense( 1279 ), 34 – 35.

Free download pdf