Cities of God: The Religion of the Italian Communes 1125-1325

(Darren Dugan) #1

 44 LaCitadeSancta


structure of twelve columns. The medieval church of the Ascension in Bolo-


gna was, however, a cruciform structure quite different from the original in


Jerusalem.^174 Petronio’s Latin life tells us that during the thirteenth century


the monks and city added further embellishments, making the sanctuary


even more vividly a reproduction of Jerusalem. Among these was a ‘‘Column


of the Flagellation’’ and a basin (extant today in the courtyard and actually


Lombard) representing the ‘‘Washbowl of Pilate’’ (fig. 33 ).^175 With the com-


plex complete in this form, the citizens of Bologna could experience the


spiritual benefits of pilgrimage to the holiest sites of Christendom without


ever leaving home. Santo Stefano assimilated the city of Bologna to the Holy


City itself, and by that association suggested that the city was a representa-


tion on earth of the Heavenly City.^176 Until the coming of the mendicants, it


was, after the duomo, the geographic locus of spiritual power in the city.


TheCityClergy


People are as important to a city as buildings, indeed more important. The


ecclesiastical geography of the communes included the clergy, a group of


men who, as the canonist Gratian said, belonged to a ‘‘genus’’ of Christians


distinct from the laity.^177 At their head stood the bishop. In 1260 , when


Bishop Giacomo Buoncambio of Bologna died suddenly at his country house


in Massimatico, they brought him to the city for burial.^178 This somewhat


trivial incident suggests that although the bishop was the chief priest of the


diocese and the single most important figure of the Mother Church, he was


not always a physical presence in the commune. To the average citizen, a


bishop was most important ritually. As the universal baptizer of the city, he


was everyone’s spiritual father.^179 This did not mean, however, that people


looked to him as a spiritual guide. Bishop Giacomo was somewhat excep-


tional. As a former Dominican with a reputation for piety, he would have


given sage advice. He became bishop, in part at least, because his skills


qualified him for the office. In contrast, well into the 1100 s and beyond,


aristocratic families monopolized election to the bishopric in most cities.^180


Politics played as large a role as piety in those elections.


In the precommunal order, the bishops were also agents of the imperial


administration. This would change as the cities threw off imperial control.


In Piacenza, the independent commune arrived with relatively little conflict.



  1. Ousterhout, ‘‘Church of Santo Stefano,’’ 315 – 16 ; see also Bologna, Biblioteca Universitaria,ms
    1473 , fols. 260 r–v—Vita S. Petronii, 2. 14 ,AS 50 (Oct.ii), 459 —and Lanzoni,San Petronio, 232.

  2. Bologna, Biblioteca Universitaria,ms 2060,c. 37 , fol. 16 r; Guidicini,Vita, 90 ; Corti,Vita, 36 – 39 ;
    discussion: Lanzoni,San Petronio, 167 – 71.

  3. On this dual significance of Jerusalem, see Sorbelli, ‘‘Sancta Jerusalem,’’ 23 – 24.

  4. Gratian,Decretum,C. 12 q. 1 c. 7.

  5. Matteo Griffoni ( 1260 ), 15.

  6. Cattaneo, ‘‘Battistero,’’ 185 – 86.

  7. See Mauro Ronzani, ‘‘Vescovi, capitoli e strategie famigliari nell’Italia comunale,’’Storia d’Italia:
    Annali(Turin: Einaudi, 1986 ), 9 : 103 – 48.

Free download pdf