The History of Mathematical Proof in Ancient Traditions

Dichotomy 3

P

versus

Th^

Type of divergence

a^

Textual element

In Books i to ix

In Books x to xiii

(+ / –)

Propositions

VII

.20

vulgo

exists in

Th

& gr. lat.

In mg. by a late hand in

P^

VII

.22

vulgo

exists in

Th

& gr. lat.

In mg. by a late hand in

P^

X.13

vulgo

exists in

Th

& gr. lat.

In mg. by hand

2 in

P^

Porisms

II.4 Por. exists in

Th

& gr. lat. by a late hand in

P^

Does not exist in Pap. Oxyrh.29 V.4 Por. exists in

Th

& in gr.-lat.

V.4 Por. in mg. by a late hand in

P^

V.7 Por. exists in

P but not in

Th

V.19 Por. exists in

Th

& in gr.-lat.

V.19 Por. in mg. by hand 1 in

P^

IX

.11 Por. exists in only

P^

Additional material S p e c i a l c a s e

C a s e

+ in

VI

.27 in

Th

& gr. lat.

In mg. by a late hand in

P^

Additions

In

III

.16 Por. N°2 exists in

Th^

& gr. lat.

In mg. by a late hand in

P^

In

V.4 exists in

Th

& in gr. lat., but not in

P^

In

VI

.33 for ‘sector’ with modifi

cations of the statement and

of the discussion in

Th

and gr. lat. In mg. by a late hand in

P^