- Bonum est non edere carnem, nec vinum
bibere,^431 nec aliud facere in quo frater tuus
concidat, vel offendatur, vel infirmetur.
21.It is good neither to eat flesh, nor to drink
wine, nor any thing whereby thy brother
stumbleth, or is offended, or is made weak.
19.Let us then follow, etc. He recalls us, as much as possible, from a mere regard to meats, to
consider those greater things which ought to have the first place in all our actions, and so to have
the precedence. We must indeed eat, that we may live; we ought to live, that we may serve the
Lord; and he serves the Lord, who by benevolence and kindness edifies his neighbor; for in order
to promote these two things, concord and edification, all the duties of love ought to be exercised.
Lest this should be thought of little moment, he repeats the sentence he had before announced, —
that corruptible meat is not of such consequence that for its sake the Lord’s building should be
destroyed. For wherever there is even a spark of godliness, there the work of God is to be seen;
which they demolish, who by their unfeeling conduct disturb the conscience of the weak.
But it must be noticed, that edification is joined to peace; because some, not unfrequently, too
freely indulge one another, so that they do much harm by their compliances. Hence in endeavoring
to serve one another, discretion ought to be exercised, and utility regarded, so that we may willingly
grant to our brother whatever may be useful to further his salvation. So Paul reminds us in another
place: “All things,” he says, “arelawful to me; but all things are not expedient;” and immediately
he adds the reason, “Because all things do not edify.” (1 Corinthians 10:23.)
Nor is it also in vain that he repeats again, For meat destroy not,^432 etc., intimating, that he
required no abstinence, by which there would be, according to what he had said before, any loss
to piety: though we eat not anything we please, but abstain from the use of meats for the sake of
our brethren; yet the kingdom of God continues entire and complete.
20.All things are indeed pure, etc. By saying, that all things are pure, he makes a general
declaration; and by adding, that it is evil for man to eat with offense, he makes an exception; as
though he had said, — “Meat is indeed good, but to give offense is bad.” Now meat has been given
to us, that we may eat it, provided love be observed: he then pollutes the use of pure meat, who by
it violates love. Hence he concludes, that it is good to abstain from all things which tend to give
offense to our brethren.
He mentions three things in order, to fall, to stumble, to be weakened: the meaning seems to
be this, — “Let no cause of falling, no, nor of stumbling, no, nor of weakening, be given to the
brethren.” For to be weakened is less than to stumble, and to stumble is less than to fall. He may
be said to be weakened whose conscience wavers with doubt, — to stumble when the conscience
is disturbed by some greater perplexity, and to fall when the individual is in a manner alienated
from his attention to religion.^433
(^431) Jerome often employed the former part of this verse for the purpose of encouraging nomasticism; and by thus disconnecting
it from the context, he got a passage quite suitable to his purpose. Even Erasmus condemned this shameful perversion. — Ed.
(^432) This is a similar, but not the same sentence as in Romans 14:15. The verb is different, ; which means to undo, to loosen,
to pull down; and as “work” follows, which, as Calvin and others think, is to be understood of God’s building, the work of
edifying or building up his people, the verb may in this sense be rendered here, “Pull not down the work of God.” But here, as
in Romans 14:15, it is the tendency of the deed that is to be considered, and the effect as far as man’s doing was concerned. The
Apostle says nothing of what God would do. — Ed.
(^433) What is said here proves what is stated in a note on Romans 14:13; that is, that is a less evil than μμ , only that
the idea of stumbling, instead of hindrance or impediment, is given here to the former word. The Apostle still adopts, as it were,
the ascending scale. He first mentions the most obvious effect, the actual fall, the extreme evil, and then the next to it, the obstacle