P1: JDT
WL040C-16 WL040/Bidgolio-Vol I WL040-Sample.cls June 19, 2003 17:12 Char Count= 0
198 REALESTATE01020304050607080(^90) Marketing, Publicity,
Information Dissemination
Customer Contact and
Service
Internal Communication
Virt
Source: FCREUE survey, 2000
ual
Communities/Multilateral
Collaborative Work
Sales Related
%
Figure 1: Web use by real estate businesses.
other housing information, and pricing comparisons
(both on houses and mortgages), with follow-up contact
with brokers. A significant volume of real estate related
transactions is seen in the hospitality industry (making
reservations for hotels and vacation homes), and to some
extent in online mortgage applications (see Table 4 for
how consumers and businesses use the Web in real estate
transactions).
Surveys carried out by the Graphics Visualization and
Usability Center (GVU) at the College of Computing, Geor-
gia Institute of Technology, help us to understand the
demographic and other determinants of people who ac-
cess real estate sites. GVU has been carrying out these
online surveys on growth and trends in Internet usage
since 1994, and they cover issues of demographics, us-
age patterns, attitudes, social standing, commercial us-
age and occupation, among others. The authors have
carried out an analysis based on GVUs downloadable
raw data of the tenth survey carried out in 1998; see
http://www.gvu.gatech.edu/usersurveys/.
Of the range of variables covered in the survey, the vari-
able “Real Estate Access” is of particular relevance. These
data were used to estimate a probit equation. Responses
involving accessing of real estate sites at any frequency
were coded as 1 and not having ever accessed any site as
- This became the dependent variable. The explanatory
variables are education (college and above=1), gender
(male=1), age (below 30=1), and usage pattern vari-
ables that were coded in a similar way.
The results of the probit estimation are shown in Table
5 as marginal effects, or transformed probit coefficients.
The probability of accessing real estate Web sites in-
Table 5Marginal Effects on Accessing of Real Estate Web
SitesIndependent Marginal Standard
Variables Effect ErrorsCollege Education 0. 04 0. 017
Age 0. 075 0. 017
Male − 0. 06 0. 018
Searching for Product 0. 06 0. 025
Information
Internet Shopping 0. 10 0. 017
Income 0. 038 0. 02Note: All coefficients, except for the one on the income variable, are
significant at the 5% confidence level. Pseudo R2=0.08;N=3206; log
likelihood=−2087.creases with college education (4%), youth (<35 years;
7.5%), household income (>$75,000; 3.8%), and de-
creases if the Web surfer is male (6%). The probability
also increases if Web usage is with the purpose of looking
for product information (6%) and for shopping on the In-
ternet (10%). Since the sample has some selection issues,
the results can be considered only indicative. Perhaps the
coefficient on the age variable is the somewhat surprising,
but since the survey did not differentiate between access-
ing real estate Web sites for purposes of renting, research-
ing, or with a view to purchasing, it is possible that young
renters were a sizeable part of the sample. Of the total
sample of 3,206 respondents, more than a third (1,226)
had accessed real estate Web sites.CONCLUDING REMARKS: THE
EMERGING STRUCTURE OF NEW
E-COMMERCE REAL ESTATE MARKETS
Impact on Real Estate Firms
The interaction of traditional real estate markets with e-
commerce is having an impact on both real estate firms
and on real estate markets. For existing firms, a major
adjustment is to incorporate the Internet directly in their
operations. At the same time, a new generation of firms is
entering the market, some providing traditional services
with e-commerce techniques and others providing new
services of value in the marketplace.Table 4A Real Estate-Oriented View of the WebPoint of View of Real Point of View of Real
Estate Business Estate Consumer
Marketing/Publicity Product Information Research
Customer Service Price and Attributes Comparison
Direct, Instantaneous Feedback Communication
& Communication Ease & Convenience of Ordering,
Customer Support Payment, Delivery and After-Sales
Online Sales Service