Influences on people management systems is developing countries
Post-colonial
Post-instrumental
Humanistic
Main principles
Theory X
Theory Y
Humanistic
Western/post-independence
Western/‘modern’
Ubuntu
African
Functionalist
Community collectivism
Instrumental
Importance
Continuing legacy through
Looked to as alternative
Some elements may prevail in
political and economic
Influence from
indigenous organizations, in
interests
multinationals,
African
Ubuntu
and Indian HRD
management education
Of growing interest
and consultants
internationally
Strategy
Inputs and process orientation
Results and market oriented
Stakeholder orientation
Lack of results and objectives
Clear objectives
Risk aversive
Calculated risk taking
Governance and
Hierarchical
Flatter hierarchy
Flatter hierarchy
decision making
Centralized
Often decentralized
Decentralized and closer to
Authoritarian
Often consultative
stakeholders
Non-consultative
Increasing emphasis on
Participative, consensus
Rule bound
‘empowerment’
seeking (
indaba
)
Lack of flexibility
Clear rules of action
Benign rules of action
Outside influence or control
Flexible
Outside influence (government,
(family, government) often
Outside government
family) may be seen as more
seen as negative
influence decreasing
benign
Character
May not act ethically towards
More ethically responsible
Stakeholder interest may be
stakeholders
Aims to be successful
more important than ‘ethics’
Not very efficient
Change is a feature
Success related to development
Static
Probably foreign owned
and wellbeing of its people
Probably not foreign owned
Indigenous
(Continued)
TABLE 9.1