Without Disclosing My True Identity
the earth” with the power to do so), he married many women and began having sexual
relations with them. Within six months after Joseph’s death, Brigham Young married 10
more wives. In 1845, he married 5 more, and another 21 in 1846.^103
How can the rational mind bearing any semblance of morality justify the wives
that Brigham Young took immediately after Joseph’s death when, while the “only man on
the earth” (Joseph) with the ostensible authority to authorize a plural marriage was alive,
Young was limited to only one plural “spiritual wife”?^104 The same dissonance also exists
when considering the wives that Heber C. Kimball took. Fittingly, Kimball would later be
called to serve as Young’s First Assistant in his new Church Presidency.^105 As will be
disclosed in the information presented in chapter 37 (1842), the revelation on plural
marriage was necessary because Brigham Young and so many other Mormon men began
to desire more than one wife without Joseph’s permission.
Emma was a smart woman who never condoned the practice of polygamy in the
first place. Once her husband was dead and she saw the way that the LDS men were
snatching up wives right and left and producing mortal children from what was
supposed to be a “spiritual” relationship, is it any wonder why she didn’t accept
Brigham Young to take Joseph’s place? The revulsion with which Emma looked on, as
this newly unfettered “priesthood” carried on with such shameless
“control...dominion...[and] compulsion upon the souls”^106 of these acquiescent women,
forced Emma deep into the backdrop of Brigham’s enveloping new religion.
The Issue of Succession
Before Sidney Rigdon and Brigham Young returned to Nauvoo following the deaths
of Joseph and Hyrum Smith,^107 the people had already heard what Joseph said prior to his
death from the account of those who were present on the evening of the 26th, as recorded
above. Sidney arrived first^108 and attempted to calm the people by telling them that he had
received a direct revelation appointing him “Guardian of the Church.”^109 Brigham arrived a
few days later; and the battle for control of the church began. A conference was to be held
on August 8, 1844 to sort out the conflict.
Brigham met first with the men who had reported their last conversations with
Joseph. Young had them recount exactly what they remembered. Each of their testimonies
supported the other’s and confirmed what Joseph had said about Hyrum. Brigham Young
had a dilemma on his hands. He couldn’t very well discount what Joseph had said; but
because Hyrum was dead, he had to make something out of the prophecy.^110
After conversing with the Twelve Apostles, minus William Smith,^111 Young decided
to visit the grieving family of Hyrum and discuss the matter with them before the
conference. Brigham and Heber C. Kimball visited Hyrum’s wives, Mary and Mercy, and
Hyrum’s six children: Lovina, age 16; Johnny, age 11; Jerusha, age 8; Sarah, age 6; Joseph F.,
age 5; and Martha, age 3, on August 7, 1844.^112 Emma’s household and close friends knew
nothing of that meeting.
Brigham told Hyrum’s grieving family that the Church would do all it could to care
for them. Brigham conveniently assigned the task to Heber Kimball, who readily accepted
the calling. (As mentioned above, barely a month passed before Kimball and Mary were
married.) Young proceeded to explain to the family what Joseph meant when he said that
Hyrum would continue the Lord’s work. He promised the family that they and their