274 PROGRESSING HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
Table 16.1.Sample of Heller’s norms and maxims adapted for the HR manager’s context
The Universal Orientative Principle of Care in Organizations
- Have a proper regard for employees’ vulnerability.
(a) Do not offend employees in their person and in anything they hold dear.
(b) Be civil and urbane, and learn to appropriately express your feelings towards employees.
(c) Help employees to save face. - Have a proper regard for employees’ autonomy.
(a) Do not violate an employee’s body.
(b) Do not violate an employee’s soul.
(c) Do not manipulate employees.
(d) Do not keep employees in tutelage.
(e) Help employees achieve greater autonomy. - Have a proper regard for employees’ morality.
(a) If your opinion holds weight in the deliberations of employees you must warn them every time they
embark on a wrong, bad, criminal, or evil course of action. Moreover every time the application of
norms is flawed, you should stand up to protect the cause of justice.
(b) Pay attention to the moral merit of employees.
(c) Learn how and when to pass moral judgements on employees.
(d) Learn when to forget and when to remember. - Have a proper regard for employees’ suffering.
(a) A decent manager notices the suffering of others.
(b) A decent manager does his or her best to alleviate another person’s sufferings. - Have a proper regard for the value of each employee∗
(a) Give credit to each employee for his or her contributions and opinions.
(b) Foster each employee’s sense of self-worth and esteem.
The ’Maxim of Justice’
Consistently and continuously apply the same norms and values to each and every employee member of the
(organizational, divisional, departmental, occupational, professional, trade, or other) cluster to which the rules
and norms apply.
Moral Maxims
The categorical and orientative universal maxim—never treat an employee as a mere means but also as an
end in himself or herself.
1.Categorical(prohibitive): never commit acts, follow norms and values, join/remain in organizations that by
definition or in principle use employees as mere means.
2.Orientative: never treat an employee as a mere means but also as an end in himself or herself.
First-order Maxims
Prohibitive Maxims - Do not choose maxims (or norms) which cannot be made public.
- Do not choose values (or norms) the observance of which involves in principle the use of employees as
mere means. - Do not choose moral norms (binding norms) the observance of which is not an end-in-itself.
Imperative Maxims - Give equal recognition to all employees as free and rational beings.
- Recognize all human needs except those the satisfaction of which in principle involves the use of
employees as mere means. - Respect (give esteem to, admire) employees only according to their (moral) merits and virtues.
∗This principle is an addition to Heller’s work.