Is Belief in God Good, Bad or Irrelevant?: A Professor and a Punk Rocker Discuss Science, Religion, Naturalism & Christianity

(Greg DeLong) #1

Dear Greg:


I am being thoroughly irresponsible by writing. I should be reading in preparation for a public lecture I
have to give in two weeks-but I won't be able to write again till tomorrow evening.


If the Ivy League paleontologist said that evolution is the fruit of "God's love," then I applaud you for
challenging him, and I wish I could have been there to challenge him alongside you, albeit from a different
perspective.


If you go back and read your description of the world (parasites, etc.), then you pretty much have
described my view, and you may be surprised to know that your view is (it seems to me) much closer to a
biblical "perspective" than the one apparently pronounced last week at the lecture you attended. (Pardon
me for a second as I turn on The Gray Race.... )


The traditional Christian view is that all the world-all of nature-is warped as a consequence of the
Fall, i.e., man's rebellion against God.


INQUIRY BOX

When    Christians  refer   to  the Fall,   they    are usually referring   to  an  event   described   early   in  the book    of
Genesis: Adam and Eve lost their moral perfection as a result of their disobedience to God. They ate
from the one tree in the Garden of Eden that God commanded them not to. Paradise was lost.

Some    Christians  interpret   this    story   literally.  Others  say that    the story   of  the Fall    describes,  in  a
literary way that is still divinely inspired, a basic truth about human beings: You can put them in
paradise, give them everything they want, and they will wreck it.

C.  S.  Lewis,  a   professor   of  English at  Oxford  and Cambridge,  wrote   that    as  a   result  of  the Fall,
people have become "ill-adapted to the universe." Another scholar, David Lyle Jeffrey, suggests that
the story in Genesis points to the "fragmentation," "alienation" and "estrangement" that people often
feel. They feel this way because they are out of sync with the way things should be and the way God
wants things to be.

Does    it  seem    to  you that    people  are "fallen"?   Does    life    seem    alien   to  people? If  very    few people
like being lonely, why is loneliness so common? Does it seem to you that people do things to
sabotage their own plans? Why would people do such things? Why do people want the world to be
better but do things to make it worse?

I   know    you don't   believe that,   but at  least   that    view    takes   the nature  of  the real    world   seriously.

But the longer I live in American Christendom, where anxieties are medicated with TV, junk food and
political slogans, the more I realize that American Christians don't really want to take the idea of
fallenness seriously.


The view expressed last week in your lecture hall comes from a well-fed, upper-middle-class Western
Christian apparently cut off from the tradition he purports to stand in. I don't know him, and I can't

Free download pdf