318
The geographic center of evolution for the Bromus species that are invasive in
the Western USA is between the Middle East and eastern Europe (Sales 1994 ;
Atkinson and Brown 2015 ), the region of origins of plant and animal domestication
(about 10,000 years BP; Flannery 1969 ). Bromus seeds were associated with
humans from at least 5000 years BP and likely earlier (Sales 1994 ; Marinova 2003 ;
White et al. 2014 ). Thus, they had ample time to evolve with both crops and domes-
tic livestock grazing. The annual life cycle is one adaptation that imparts grazing
tolerance to these species. As populations of B. tectorum decrease in one generation,
Past Selection Pressure
Grazing history
Plant community before
each grazing episode
Soil texture, depth,
temperature & moisture
regime
Grazing Action
Injury to individual plants?
Plant community during
a grazing event
Grazing use/intensity
differs among life-forms in
community
Community Reaction
Death or Regrowth of
Injured individuals
Community after
grazing event
Response of community
composition & structure
Past Selection Pressure
Annual Bromus Native Herbaceous
Community
Environment Graze Environment Graze Reaction
Great
Plains -+++NH => AB
Cold
Desert +++--AB >> NH
Warm
Desert +++--AB >> NH
Med.
California +++--AB >> NH
Fig. 11.2 Plant community structure (above) as shaped by grazing during grazing events, by the
community’s response to the grazing, and by the past selection pressures including the environ-
ment and grazing among the grazed plants at the site of evolution (modifi ed from Milchunas et al.
1988 ). In the table (below), negative (−) and positive (+) signs indicate degree of adaptation for
annual Bromus species (AB) and native herbaceous species (NH) to environments of four ecore-
gions and to grazing during the active growing season. Under community reaction, equal than
and greater than signs (>) refl ect dominance strength of AB and NH based on these adaptations
D.A. Pyke et al.