IFR - 07.07.2018

Upfront

„ OPINION INTERNATIONAL FINANCING REVIEW

Running out of money

L

oan bankers love to think that they are made of sterner

STUFFûTHANûTHEûlCKLEûFOLKûOFûTHEûBONDûMARKET

!NDûWHENûITûCOMESûTOû)TALIANûINFRASTRUCTUREûOPERATORû

!TLANTIAûTHEYûHAVEûAûPOINT

7ITHûTHEûBONDûMARKETSûREFUSINGûTOûFUNDûTHEûCOMPANYûATû

ACCEPTABLEûLEVELSûFORûTHEûGOODûREASONûTHATû)TALIANûRISKûLOOKSû

PRETTYûWELLûRISKY ûUPûSTEPPEDûTHEûLENDERSûINCLUDINGûlVEû

)TALIANûBANKS   ûTOûPROVIDEûAûõBNûlVE

YEARûTERMûLOANûATûVERYû

ATTRACTIVEûLEVELSû$ISINTERMEDIATIONû7HATû

DISINTERMEDIATION

'OODûNEWSûFORû!TLANTIAûOFûCOURSEû"UTûCANûITûLAST

!ûPOTENTIALûANSWERûTOûTHATûQUESTIONûWASûPROVIDEDûBYûTWOû

OTHERû)TALIANûDEALSûTHATûGOTûDONEûnûJUSTûnûLASTûWEEKûCOVEREDû

BONDûISSUESûFROMû)NTESAû3ANPAOLOûANDû-EDIOBANCA

9ESûTHEûDEALSûMADEûITûOVERûTHEûLINEûBUTûTHEYûWEREû

EXPENSIVEûFORûTHEûISSUERSûANDû-EDIOBANCAûSTRUGGLEDûTOûSELLûAû

BONDûOFFERINGûTHATûINûTHEûENDûONLYûRAISEDûõM

4HEûFACTûTHATû)TALIANûBANKSûAREûHAVINGûTOûPAYûUPûSOûMUCHûEVENû

FORûCOVEREDûBONDSûANDûASûITûSTANDSûAREûNOTûEVENûATTEMPTINGûTOû

SELLûRACIERûBANKûCAPITALûBONDSûISûSOMETHINGûTOûPONDER

9ESûTHEYûAREûWELLûFUNDEDûBUTûMUCHûOFûTHATûFUNDINGûHASû

COMEûFROMûTHEû%#"ûnû)TALIANûBANKSûHAVEûBORROWEDûANû

ESTIMATEDûõBNûINûINITIALûDRAWINGSûFROMûTHEû4,42/û))

!NDûWITHûTHATûSCHEMEûENDINGûEARLIERûTHISûYEARûANDûRETAILû

INVESTORSûANûIMPORTANTûSOURCEûOFûlNANCINGûNOWûOFFûLIMITS  ûITû

WONTûBEûEASYûFORûTHEûCOUNTRYSûBANKSûTOûBUILDûUPûLAYERSûOFûLOSS

ABSORBINGûDEBTûNECESSARYûTOûMEETûGLOBALûANDû%UROPEANûSTANDARDS

'IVENûTHATûBACKGROUNDûITûISûNOTûENTIRELYûFANCIFULûTOûTHINKû

THATûTHEû%#"ûMIGHTûHAVEûTOûLAUNCHûANOTHERûVERSIONûOFûTHEû

4,42/ûRATHERûTHANûSEEûSOMEû)TALIANûLENDERSûEFFECTIVELYûRUNû

OUTûOFûFUNDINGûOPTIONS

)NûTHEûENDûITûDOESNTûMATTERûHOWûBIGûAûLENDERSûRISKû

APPETITEûISûIFûTHEYûHAVENTûGOTûANYûMONEYûTOûLEND

Lehman pay-off

/

NûTHEûMORNINGûOFû3EPTEMBERûûûINVESTORSûINû

lNANCIALûASSETSûHADûFEWûOPTIONSûOFûWHEREûTOûTURNûFORû

SAFETYûAFTERûTHEûUNTHINKABLEûHAPPENEDûANDûONEûOFûTHEûWORLDSû

LEADINGûINVESTMENTûBANKSû,EHMANû"ROTHERSûlLEDûFORû

BANKRUPTCYûPROTECTION

/NEûOPTIONûnûAûCOMPARATIVEûSAFEûHAVENûnûWASû*0û-ORGANû

!NDûSUREûENOUGHûINûTHEûWEEKûAFTERû,EHMANûlLEDûANDûWHILEû

OTHERûBANKSûWEREûTEETERINGûONûTHEûEDGEûOFûOBLIVION  û*0û

-ORGANSûSHARESûROSEûûTOû53

!SûTHEûTHûANNIVERSARYûOFûTHEû,EHMANûlLINGûAPPROACHESû

those shares have turned out to be one of the best

INVESTMENTSûINûTHEûlNANCIALûSECTORûOVERûTHATûLONGERûPERIODû

RISINGûBYûTWO

AND

A

HALFûTIMESûTOû53

!NDûYETûTHATûRETURNûPALESûINTOûINSIGNIlCANCEûAGAINSTûWHATû

DISTRESSEDûINVESTORSûSTANDûTOûRECEIVEûFROMûBUYINGûUPûCREDITORû

CLAIMSûAGAINSTû,EHMANû"ROTHERSûANDûITSûVARIOUSûSUBSIDIARIESû

INCLUDINGûITSûMAINû,ONDONûSUBSIDIARYû,EHMANû"ROTHERSû

)NTERNATIONAL  û%UROPE

3OûFARûCREDITORSûOFûTHISûENTITYûHAVEûBEENûPAIDûINûFULLû

MEANINGûTHOSEûWHOûBOUGHTûTHEûCLAIMSûREPORTEDLYûINûSOMEû

CASESûFORûASûLITTLEûASûPûINûTHEûPOUNDûHAVEûALREADYûGOTûBACKû

lVEûTIMESûTHATûINITIALûINVESTMENT

4HATûWOULDûHAVEûBEENûGOODûENOUGHûCERTAINLYûCOMPAREDû

WITHûMANYûOTHERû&)'ûINVESTMENTSû"UTû,")%ûCREDITORSûHAVEû

ALSOûBENElTEDûFROMûTHEûGENEROUSûûSTATUTORYûRATEûOFûINTERESTû

PAIDûONûTHEûCLAIMSû4HATûISûûTIMESû5+ûBASEûRATEûANDûHASûNOTû

CHANGEDûFORûDECADES

,")%ûCREDITORSûCANûNOWûEXPECTûTOûRECEIVEûATûLEASTûANûADDITIONALû

PûAFTERûTHEû(IGHû#OURTûOFû%NGLANDûANDû7ALESûAPPROVEDûAû

SCHEMEûPROPOSEDûBYû,")%SûJOINTûADMINISTRATORû0W#ûTOû

DISTRIBUTEûTHEûSURPLUSûTHATûHASûBUILTûUPûTOûTHEMû4HATûWILLûGIVEû

THEMûPûBACKûOVERALLûnûORûUPûTOûSEVENûTIMESûTHEIRûMONEY

&EWûWOULDûHAVEûIMAGINEDûTHATûONEûOFûTHEûBESTû&)'û

INVESTMENTSûSINCEûTHEûCRISISûSTARTEDûBYûTHEûFALLûOFû,EHMANû

WOULDûHAVEûBEENû,EHMANûITSELFû(ATSûOFFûTOûTHOSEûTHATûDID

High stakes

A

TûSOMEûPOINTû!SIANûHIGH

YIELDûBONDSûWILLûBECOMEûANû

ENORMOUSûBUYINGûOPPORTUNITYû2IGHTûNOWûHOWEVERûITû

WOULDûTAKEûAûBRAVEûFUNDûMANAGERûTOûMAKEûTHATûBET

!FTERûAûSPECTACULARûROUTûINû53ûDOLLARûBONDSûFROMûJUNK

RATEDû

#HINESEûISSUERSûTHEûAVERAGEûYIELDûONûAûlVE

YEARû!SIANûHIGH

YIELDûBONDûISûNOWûHIGHERûTHANûATûANYûPOINTûSINCEû*ULYû

!ûSPATEûOFûDEFAULTûSCARESûFROMûTHEûLIKESûOFû#HINAû%NERGYû2ESERVEû

û#HEMICALû'ROUPûANDû7UZHOUû)NTERNATIONALûHAVEûSAPPEDû

CONlDENCEûINûTHEûSECTORûATûAûTIMEûWHENûRISINGû53û4REASURYûYIELDSû

AREûALREADYûDENTINGûGLOBALûDEMANDûFORûEMERGING

MARKETûASSETS

#HINASûCAMPAIGNûTOûDELEVERAGEûTHEûlNANCIALûSECTORûANDûANû

ONGOINGûBATTLEûTOûSTEMûRISINGûHOUSEûPRICESûHAVEûPILEDûONû

MOREûPRESSUREûFORCINGûMOREûISSUERSûTOûBORROWûOVERSEASûANDû

SHUTTINGûSOMEûINVESTORSûOUTûOFûTHEûOFFSHOREûMARKET

-ANYû#HINESEûPROPERTYûCOMPANIESûHAVEûREPRICEDûTHEIRû

OWNûCURVESûBYûTAPPINGûRECENTûISSUESûATûFARûHIGHERûYIELDSûnû

OFTENûWELLûINTOûTHEûDOUBLEûDIGITSûnûINûDESPERATIONûTOûKEEPû

THEIRûFUNDINGûLINESûOPEN

!SûAûRESULTûWELL

KNOWNûNAMESûSUCHûASû+AISAû'ROUPû3UNACû

ANDû&ANTASIAûNOWûOFFERûYIELDSûOFûOVERûû+AISASûû*UNEû

SûAREûATû 

3EASONEDûINVESTORSûWILLûNOûDOUBTûSEEûPARALLELSûWITHû

PREVIOUSûSELL

OFFSûINûTHEûVOLATILEû#HINESEûPROPERTYûSECTORû

WHENûTHOSEûWHOûBOUGHTûINûATûTHEûBOTTOMûREAPEDûHUGEû

REWARDSûONCEûCONCERNSûABOUTûONSHOREûlNANCINGûCURBSû

ULTIMATELYûEVAPORATED

3OûFARûGLOBALûINVESTORSûHAVEûSHOWNûLITTLEûINTERESTûINûGETTINGû

BACKûINûTHEûGAMEû2ECENTûHIGH

YIELDûISSUESûHAVEûGONEûALMOSTû

ENTIRELYûTOû#HINA

LINKEDûINVESTORSûWHOûMAYûBEûMOREûFAMILIARû

WITHû#HINESEûISSUERSûORûSIMPLYûHAVEûFEWERûALTERNATIVESûTOû

CONSIDERûUNDERûTHEIRûMANDATES

4HISûTIMEûAROUNDûAûSLOWDOWNûINûOFFSHOREûISSUANCEûANDûAû

GRADUALûEASINGûOFûONSHOREûLIQUIDITYûWILLûEVENTUALLYûRESTOREû

CONlDENCEûINûTHEûTOPûNAMESûBUTûAûRAPIDûREBOUNDûFORûTHEû

ENTIREûSECTORûLOOKSûUNLIKELYû4IGHTERû#HINESEûREGULATIONSû

MEANûTHEûMASSIVEûINmOWSûOFûûANDûûFROMûHIGHLYû

LEVERAGEDûINVESTORSûMAYûNEVERûRETURNûANDûMOREûMARGINALû

ISSUERSûWILLûSLIDEûINTOûDEFAULT

"RAVEûFUNDûMANAGERSûMAYûSTILLûlNDûFORTUNEûATûTODAYSû

PRICESûBUTûTHEYûWILLûHAVEûTOûCHOOSEûWISELY