Upfront
OPINION^ INTERNATIONAL FINANCING REVIEWSwap this
T
HEûlNANCEûINDUSTRYûHASûAûWELL
DEVELOPEDûABILITYûTOûPUNCHû
ITSELFûINûTHEûFACEû"UTûNOûPARTûOFûTHEûMARKETûISûBETTERûATû
DOINGûTHATûTHANûTHEûCREDITûDEFAULTûSWAPûMARKET
4HEûLATESTûSHENANIGANSûREALLYûTAKEûTHEûCAKE
"LACKSTONESûCREDITûARMû'3/ûISûFACINGûSTEEPûLOSSESûONû#$3û
CONTRACTSûITûBOUGHTûLINKEDûTOûJUNK
RATEDû(OVNANIAN ûWHICHû
LIKEûAûLOTûOFû53ûHOME
BUILDERSûGOTûPUMMELLEDûINûTHEû
MORTGAGEûMELTDOWNûBUTûHASûSINCEûSHOWNûSIGNSûOFûLIFEû)TSû
SHARESûAREûUPûSOMEûûOVERûTHEûPASTûYEAR
.OW û(OVNANIANûWANTSûTOûRElNANCEûSOMEûDEBTûINûAû
COMPLICATEDûDEBTûSWAPû'3/ûISûOFFERINGûTHEûCOMPANYûANû
ULTRA
LOWûCOSTûLOANûTOûHELPûOUTûnûIFû(OVNANIANûSKIPSûSOMEû
BONDûPAYMENTSûONûEXISTINGûDEBTûINûRETURN ûWHICHûWOULDû
TRIGGERûAûCREDITûEVENTûTHATûWOULDûPAYûOUTû'3/SûSWAPSû
CONTRACTS
-OREOVER ûASûPARTûOFûTHEûDEBTûSWAP û(OVNANIANûWILLûPUTû
TOGETHERûAûNEWûBONDûISSUEûWITHûSUCHûAûLOWûCOUPONûANDûLONGû
MATURITYûTHATûITSûLIKELYûTOûTRADEûWELLûUNDERûPARûnûPOSSIBLYûINû
THEûSû"UTûTHEN û(OVNANIANûWOULDûDUMPûTHATûCRAPPYûPAPERû
INTOûTHEû#$3ûAUCTION ûANDûTHUSûINmATEû'3/SûULTIMATEûPAYOUTû
EVENûMORE
%VERYONESûAûWINNERûnûEXCEPTûTHEûSELLERSûOFûTHOSEû#$3û
CONTRACTS ûOFûCOURSEû/H ûANDûTHEûMARKETûITSELF
/NEûHEDGEûFUNDûHASûALREADYûlLEDûSUITûAGAINSTûTHEûPLAN û
DENOUNCINGûITûASûhFRAUDULENTvûANDûAûhBRIBEvûnûANDûITSûNOTûTHEû
ONLYûONEûTHATûTHINKSûSOû4HEûFORMERûHEADûOFû)3$! ûFORû
EXAMPLE ûBELIEVESûTHISûCOULDûCAUSEûIRREPARABLEûHARMûTOûTHEû
#$3ûMARKET ûAûSHRINKINGûENTITYûWHOSEûNETûNOTIONALûISûNOWû
HALFûOFûWHATûITûWASûJUSTûAûFEWûYEARSûAGO
)NûFACT ûTHISûISûTHEûTHIRDûTIMEûTHATû'3/ûHASûPLAYEDûFASTûANDû
LOOSEûWITHû#$3ûTECHNICALITIESûINûORDERûTOûENRICHûTHOSEû
INVOLVEDûATûTHEûEXPENSEûOFûCOUNTERPARTIESû4HEûMARKETûWROTEû
OFFûTHEûlRSTûTWOûASûABERRATIONSû)TûCANûNOûLONGERûDOûTHAT
'IVENûTHEûEASYûMONEYûATûSTAKE ûSUCHûDEALSûWILLûBECOMEû
INCREASINGLYûCOMMONûANDûTHEûSINGLE
NAMEû#$3ûMARKETûWILLû
FALLûINTOûFURTHER ûDISREPUTEû.OûDOUBT û'3/ûISûLOOKINGûTOû
REPEATûTHEûTRICK
5NFORTUNATELY ûJUSTûASûSTRONGûVOICESûAREûREQUIREDûTOûSPEAKû
UPûFORûBESTûPRACTICE û)3$!ûITSELFûISûCONSPICUOUSûBYûITSûABSENCE
4HEûINDUSTRYûBODYûISûHAMPEREDûBYûTHEûFACTûTHATûITûOVERSEESû
THEûDETERMINATIONSûCOMMITTEE ûWHICHûULTIMATELYûRULESûONû
WHETHERûAûDEFAULTûHASûTAKENûPLACEûINûTHEû(OVNANIANûCASEû)FûITû
EXPRESSESûAûVIEWûNOW ûTHEûARGUMENTûGOES ûTHATûPROCESSûISû
UNDERMINED
"UTûAûCONVERSATIONûABOUTûHOWûTOûAVOIDûSUCHûDEBACLESûINûTHEû
FUTUREûISûVITALûANDûURGENTû#ITIGROUPûCREDITûANALYSTSûHAVEû
PROPOSEDûCHANGESûTOûTHEûLANGUAGEûTHATûTRIGGERSû#$3ûANDû
WOULDûMAKEûSUCHûBEHAVIOURûMOREûDIFlCULTûANOTHERûOPTIONû
WOULDûBEûTOûINTRODUCEûSOMEûCONSIDERATIONûOFûMOTIVATIONûINTOû
THEûRULES
%ACHûOPTIONûHASûITSûDOWNSIDESûANDûMAYûFALLûPREYûTOûTHEûLAWû
OFûUNINTENDEDûCONSEQUENCESû"UTûTHEûISSUEûISNTûGOINGûTOûGOû
AWAY
)3$!ûISûINûTHEûPROCESSûOFûPUTTINGûTHEû$#ûATûARMSûLENGTH û
ANDûTHATûMOVEûCANTûCOMEûSOONûENOUGHû)FûITûISNTûLEADINGûANDû
FACILITATINGûTHEûNECESSARYûCONVERSATION ûTHENûWHAT ûEXACTLY ûISû
ITûFOR Solving for SoftBank
!
53BNûLISTINGûOFû3OFT"ANKû'ROUPSû*APANESEûMOBILEû
PHONEûUNITûISûSETûTOûBEûTHISûYEARSûHOTTESTûTICKETûAMONGû
EQUITYûUNDERWRITERS ûBUTûAûDEALûOFûTHATûSIZEûMAYûBEûFARûLESSû
EXCITINGûFORûINVESTORS
3OFT"ANKû'ROUPûSAIDûLASTûWEEKûTHATûANû)0/ûWASûONEûOFûTHEû
OPTIONSûONûTHEûTABLE ûRESPONDINGûTOûAû.IKKEIûREPORTûTHATûTHEûGROUPû
PLANNEDûTOûmOATûTHEûPHONEûBUSINESSûINû*APANûANDûOVERSEAS
)TûLOOKSûAûLOGICALûSOLUTIONûFORûANûAMBITIOUS ûCASH
HUNGRYû
GROUPûTHATûHASûBECOMEûFARûMOREûTHANûAû*APANESEû
COMMUNICATIONSûBUSINESS ûANDûINVESTORSûRESPONDEDûWELL û
PUSHINGûITSûSTOCKûUPûûOVERûTHEûCOURSEûOFûLASTûWEEK
3OFT"ANKû'ROUPûISûARGUABLYûUNDERVALUED ûWITHûAûHIGHûDEBTû
BURDENûANDûHOLDINGûCOMPANYûSTRUCTUREûDETRACTINGûFROMûTHEû
SUMûOFûITSûPARTSûITSûSTAKEûINû!LIBABAûALONEûISûWORTHûANû
EXTRAORDINARYû53BNûMOREûTHANûITSûCURRENTû53BNû
MARKETûCAPû$OUBTLESS ûTHEûFORMERû$EUTSCHEû"ANKûEXECUTIVESû
WHOûNOWûWORKûTHEREûnûINCLUDINGûFORMERûTRADINGûHEADû#OLINû
&ANûnûWILLûBEûLOOKINGûATûSOMEûCREATIVEûWAYSûTOûUNLOCKûVALUE
"UTûAûSPIN
OFFûOFû3OFT"ANKû#ORP ûTHEûLOCALûPHONEûUNIT ûLOOKSû
LESSûINTERESTINGûTHANûTHEûHEADLINESûUSUALLYûASSOCIATEDûWITHû
-ASAYOSHIû3ONSûTECHNOLOGYûEMPIREû7HILEûTHEûGROUPûISû
PUSHINGûINTOûBOLDûNEWûFRONTIERSûnûMOSTûRECENTLYûBECOMINGû
THEûBIGGESTûSHAREHOLDERûINûRIDE
SHARINGûlRMû5BERûnû3OFT"ANKû
#ORPûOPERATESûINûTHEûMATUREû*APANESEûMOBILEûPHONEûMARKET
4HATûMAKESûTHEû)0/ûAûLOW
GROWTHûINCOMEûPLAYûRATHERûTHANû
AûNEW
ECONOMYûBLOCKBUSTERûnûCLOSERûINûSTYLEûTOûAû*APANû0OSTû
THANûANOTHERû!LIBABAû3TABLE ûCASH
GENERATINGûBUSINESSESû
HAVEûREALûAPPEALûINû*APAN ûBUTû3OFT"ANKûALREADYûHASûTWOû
BIGGERûTELECOMSûRIVALSûANDûMAYûBEûFACINGûMOREûCOMPETITION
4HEûDEALûWILLûNEEDûTOûENTICEûOVERSEASûINVESTORSûTOûHITûITSû
TARGETSû4HEû.IKKEIûREPORTEDûPLANSûTOûmOATûAûûSTAKEûLATERû
THISûYEAR ûBELOWûTHEûûMINIMUMûFORûAûPURELYûDOMESTICû)0/ û
MAKINGûAûDUALûLISTINGûTHEûMOSTûLIKELYûSCENARIO
!ûSEPARATEûLISTINGûWOULDûALLOWûINVESTORSûTOûCHOOSEûBETWEENû
AûPURE
PLAYûTELCOûANDûAûFARûRISKIERûINVESTMENTûHOLDINGû
COMPANYû7INNINGûAûHIGHûVALUATIONûFORûBOTH ûHOWEVER ûWILLû
REQUIREûAûDELICATEûMARKETINGûEXERCISE