For daily news stories
@ visit http://www.ifre.com
US tax reform lifts
Chinese bonds
Emerging Markets PRC notes offered inside Treasuries
BY DANIEL STANTON
CHINAûACHIEVEDûAûRAREûFEATûLASTûWEEKû
ASûONEûOFûITSû53ûDOLLAR
DENOMINATEDû
SOVEREIGNûBONDSûWASûQUOTEDûINSIDEû
53û4REASURIESûTHANKSûMAINLYûTOûAû
RISEûINû53ûRATESûAFTERû$ECEMBERSûTAXû
REFORMûLEGISLATION
4HEûSOVEREIGNSûû
.OVEMBERûûBONDûPRICEDûINû
/CTOBERûWASûBRIEmYûOFFEREDûONû
7EDNESDAYûATûBPûBELOWûTHEû53û
lVE
YEARûBENCHMARKûBEFOREû
RETURNINGûTOûPOSITIVEûTERRITORYû
4HEû#HINAûlVE
YEARûWASûALSOû
QUOTEDûATûAûNEGATIVEû:ûSPREADû
THROUGHOUTûTHEûWEEK
/NûTHEûBIDûSIDEûTHEû#HINAû
ûNOTEûWASûLASTûQUOTEDûBPû
WIDEûOFû53û4REASURIESûHAVINGû
TIGHTENEDûFROMûAûSPREADûATûISSUEû
OFûBP
#HINASûSûHAVEûALSOû
TIGHTENEDûAGAINSTû4REASURIESû
SINCEûTHEûSTARTûOFûTHEûYEARûTOû:û
PLUSûBPûFROMûBPûATûTHEûENDû
OFûûANDûAû4REASURYûSPREADûOFû
BPûFROMûBPû#HINAûSOLDû
53BNûOFûOVERSEASûBONDSûINû
/CTOBERûSPLITûEQUALLYûBETWEENû
SûANDûSûINûITSûlRSTû53û
DOLLARûOFFERINGûSINCEû
h#HINAûWANTEDûTOûISSUEû
SOVEREIGNûBONDSûTOûMAKEûAûPOINTû
ANDûTHEYûHAVEûDONEûITûSUCCESSFULLYvû
SAIDû,EOû(UûSENIORûPORTFOLIOû
manager of emerging markets
DEBTûATû..û)NVESTMENTû0ARTNERS
4HEûTHREEûMAJORûCREDITûRATINGû
agencies see China as a A1/A+/A+
CREDITûTHOUGHûITûPOINTEDLYûDIDûNOTû
SEEKûAûRATINGûFORûLASTûYEARSûISSUEû
AFTERûDOWNGRADESûFROMû-OODYSû
ANDû30û)NûTHEORYûITSûSOVEREIGNû
BONDSûSHOULDûTRADEûMUCHûWIDERû
than those of the US, which is a
!AA!!!!!ûCREDITûBUTûINVESTORSû
SEEMûTOûVIEWû#HINASûPROSPECTSû
MOREûPOSITIVELY
h0EOPLEûTHINKû#HINESEûCREDITû
FUNDAMENTALSûWILLûIMPROVEû
WHILEûTHEû53ûWILLûDETERIORATEû
4HEûDEBTûBURDENûOFûTHEû53ûISû
CERTAINLYûGOINGûTOûBEûANûISSUEû
WHILEû#HINAûISûTRYINGûTOûREDUCEû
ORûATûLEASTûCONTROLûLEVERAGEû4HEû
53ûTAXûPLANûWASûAûTRIGGERûFORû
MARKETSvûSAIDû(U
53û4REASURYûYIELDSûHAVEû
STEEPENEDûSINCEûTHEûPASSAGEûOFûTAXû
reform, which has cut corporate
TAXûRATESûBUTûISûESTIMATEDûTOûADDû
53TRNûTOûTHEûNATIONALûDElCITûINû
THEûNEXTûûYEARSûACCORDINGûTOûTHEû
*OINTû#OMMITTEEûONû4AXATIONûAû
NON
PARTISANûGROUPINGûOFûTHEû53û
#ONGRESSû4HEûlVE
YEARû53û
4REASURYûYIELDûHASûRISENûBPû
SINCEû$ECEMBERûûTHEûDAYûBEFOREû
THEû(OUSEûOFû2EPRESENTATIVESû
APPROVEDûTHEûTAXûBILLûANDûTHEû
YEARûYIELDûROSEûBP
/Nû4UESDAYû#HINESEûCREDITû
RATINGûAGENCYû$AGONGû'LOBALûCUTû
THEû53ûSOVEREIGNûRATINGûTOû"""û
WITHûAûNEGATIVEûOUTLOOKûFROMû
!nûSAYINGûTHEûNATIONSûDEBT
DRIVENûECONOMICûDEVELOPMENTû
WILLûWEAKENûITSûSOLVENCY
h4HEû53ûTAXûPLANûWASûAû
#HRISTMASûGIFTûBUTûSOMEONEûNEEDSû
TOûPAYûTHEûBILLvûSAIDû(Uû
h%VENTUALLYûTHEû53ûNEEDSûTOû
BORROWûMOREûSOûTHISûWILLûINCREASEû
THEûDEBTûPILEûADDûTOûTHEûlSCALûDElCITû
ANDûBORROWINGûCOSTSûWILLûINCREASEv
)NûCONTRASTû0RESIDENTû8Iû
*INPINGûMADEûITûCLEARûATûLASTû
YEARSû.ATIONALû0ARTYû#ONGRESSû
THATû#HINAûWOULDûTRYûTOû
DELEVERAGEûTHEûlNANCIALûSYSTEMû
ANDûREDUCEûSYSTEMICûRISKûWHILEû
INCREASINGûPRODUCTIVITYûTOûMOVEû
THEûCOUNTRYûUPûTHEûVALUEûCHAIN
PLAYING CATCH-UP
!ûCREDITûTRADERûSAIDûSOMEû!SIANû
SOVEREIGNûBONDSûHADûBENElTEDû
FROMûINVESTORûCAUTIONûTOWARDSû
corporate paper at the start of
THEûYEARûWITHûMANYûEXPECTINGû
SOMEûMARKETûCORRECTIONû
)NVESTORSûAREûALSOûKEENûTOûHOLDû
#HINASûSOVEREIGNûPAPERûBECAUSEû
ITûISûNOTûEXPECTEDûTOûBEûAûREGULARû
ISSUERûINûTHEûDOLLARûMARKET
h)TSûNOTûASûTHOUGHû#HINAûISû
going to come out with a new
ISSUEûTOMORROWvûSAIDûTHEûTRADER
)NûCONTRASTû#HINESEûQUASI
SOVEREIGNSûANDûINVESTMENT
GRADEû
STATE
OWNEDûENTERPRISESûDIDû
not see as much tightening in
THEIRûDOLLARûBONDSûANDûSOMEû
ANALYSTSûAREûTIPPINGûTHISûGAPûTOû
NARROWû (^)
With the humanitarian crisis
DEEPENINGûINû6ENEZUELA ûAûHARDû
DEFAULTûISûSEENûASûINCREASINGLYû
LIKELYû4HATûCOULDûUSHERûINûAûNEWû
ADMINISTRATIONûKEENERûONû
RENEGOTIATINGûALLûDEBTSûSTRUCKûBYû
PREVIOUSûGOVERNMENTS ûASûWELLû
ASûANYûAGREEMENTSûTOûSELLûOILû
UPFRONT
h3OMEûCOULDûARGUEûTHATûTHISû
;OILûSALES=ûISûAKINûTOûSELLINGûTHEû
NEXTûGOVERNMENTSûFUTUREû
REVENUEûSOURCEûSOûWHENûAûNEWû
GOVERNMENTûCOMESûTOûPOWERû
THOSEûAGREEMENTSûCOULDûBEû
RIPPEDûUPû)TSûHARDûTOûKNOWû
WHATû#HINASûRESPONSEûWOULDû
BE vûSAIDûTHEûSECONDûADVISER
#HINAûMIGHTûBEûABLEûTOûARGUEû
THAT ûASûITûPROVIDEDûCREDITûTOûTHEû
COUNTRYûAFTERûITûHADûLOSTûMARKETû
ACCESSûANDûHADûALREADYû
RENEGOTIATEDûTHEûTERMSûOFûSOMEû
OFûITSûDEBTûACCEPTINGûOILûINSTEADû
OFûCASH ûITûSHOULDûLEGALLYûBEû
REGARDEDûASûSENIORûANDûGETû
BETTERûTREATMENTûTHANûOTHERû
CREDITORS
#HINAûSHOWEDûITûCOULDûTAKEûANû
ASSERTIVEûAPPROACHûTOûDEBTORSûINû
$ECEMBERûWHENûITûTOOKû
POSSESSIONûOFû(AMBANTOTAûPORTû
INû3RIû,ANKAûAFTERûTHEûCOUNTRYû
WASûUNABLEûTOûPAYûDEBTSûSECUREDû
AGAINSTûTHEûASSET
TRANSPARENCY REQUIRED
!NYûNEGOTIATIONSûWILLûREQUIREû
#HINAûTOûBEûMOREûTRANSPARENTû
ABOUTûITSûDEBTûHOLDINGSû3OMEû
RESTRUCTURINGûSPECIALISTSûHAVEû
SUGGESTEDûITûSHOULDûPERHAPSûSETû
UPûITSûOWNû!SIANûVERSIONûOFûAû
0ARISû#LUBûTOûCOORDINATEûTHEû
NEGOTIATIONSûOFûITSûVARIOUSû
INSTITUTIONS ûANDûTHOSEûOFûITSû
CONTINENTALûALLIES
h2EFERENCEûTOû#HINESEûCLAIMSû
ISûITSELFûANûOVERSIMPLIlCATIONû
#HINESEûCREDITORSûMAYûINCLUDEû
#HINAû$EVELOPMENTû"ANK û
#HINAû%XIMû"ANK ûONEûORûMOREû
OFûTHEIRû3/%S ûANDûINVESTMENTû
VEHICLESûSUCHûASûTHEû3ILKû2OADû
&UNDû4HEYûMAYûTAKEûDIFFERINGû
APPROACHESûTOûAûPROPOSEDû
RESTRUCTURING vûSAIDû7ALKER
5LTIMATELYû#HINASûATTITUDEû
WILLûDEPENDûONûITSûPARTICULARû
POLICYûGOALSûTOWARDSûTHEûDEBTORû
h!LLûINDICATIONSûSOûFARûAREûTHATû
#HINAûISûAûBENIGNûCREDITORû;OFû
6ENEZUELA=ûANDûISûHAPPYûSOûLONGû
ASûITûCONTINUESûTOûRECEIVEûOILûATûAû
REASONABLEûPRICE vûSAIDûONEû
SOVEREIGNûDEBTûLAWYER (^)
#ARILLIONSûEXISTINGûDEBTûINTOû
EQUITY ûSEVERALûSOURCESûSAID
#ARILLIONûHELDûAûMEETINGû
WITHûCREDITORSûONû*ANUARYûû
TOûDISCUSSûITSûBUSINESSûPLANû
ANDûSAIDûTHATûITûNEEDEDûATû
LEASTûaMûTOûSUSTAINûITSû
BUSINESS
,ENDERSûSAID ûHOWEVER ûTHATû
THEYûWEREûUNABLEûTOûCOMMITû
FUNDINGûWITHOUTûGOVERNMENTû
SUPPORTûINûTHEûFORMûOFûMONEY û
GUARANTEESûORûTHEûGOVERNMENTû
TAKINGûBACKûSOMEûCONTRACTS
h,ENDERSûSUPPORTûWASû
CONTINGENTûONûGOVERNMENTû
SUPPORTû)FûTHEYûHADûTHATûSUPPORTû
THEYûWOULDûHAVEûLENTûFURTHERû
MONEYûnûMAYBEûNOTûTHEûENTIREû
aMûBUTûSOMEûMONEY vûAû
SECONDûRESTRUCTURINGûADVISERû
SAID
2"3 û3ANTANDERûANDû,LOYDSû
WEREûNOTûWILLINGûTOûEXTENDû
FURTHERûFUNDINGûAFTERûTHEû
GOVERNMENTûREFUSEDûTHATû
SUPPORTûLASTûWEEKEND ûAûSECONDû
BANKINGûSOURCEûSAID
(3"#ûANDû"ARCLAYSûWEREû
WILLINGûTOûLENDû#ARILLIONûENOUGHû
MONEYûTOûSURVIVEûANOTHERûWEEK û
BUTû#ARILLIONSûBOARDûAPPLIEDûTOû
THEûHIGHûCOURTûFORûLIQUIDATIONûONû
-ONDAY ûHEûADDED
!LTHOUGHûSOMEûLENDERSûWEREû
AWAREûTHATû#ARILLIONSûlNANCESû
WEREûNOTûSUSTAINABLEûWITHOUTû
GOVERNMENTûSUPPORTûASûEARLYûASû
$ECEMBER ûCREDITORSûWEREû
optimistic of getting
GOVERNMENTûBACKING
,ENDERSûWEREûEXPECTINGûTOû
AGREEûAûDEBTûRESTRUCTURINGûINûTHEû
lRSTûQUARTER ûBEFOREûAûSIX
MONTHû
DEBTûWAIVERûEXPIREDûINû!PRIL û
WHICHûWOULDûBEûIMPLEMENTEDû
INûTHEûSECONDûQUARTER
h7EûWEREûVERYûHOPEFULûTOûGETû
AûDEALûDONEûITûISûVERYû
DISAPPOINTING vûAûTHIRDû
RESTRUCTURINGûADVISERûSAID
(3"#ûANNOUNCEDûLASTû
4HURSDAYûAûaMûEMERGENCYû
FUNDûFORû#ARILLIONSûSMALLû
BUSINESSûSUPPLIERSûWHICHû
WILLûOFFERûPAYMENTûHOLIDAYSû
ANDûHELPûWITHûFEESû2"3ûISû
OFFERINGûaMûOFûASSISTANCEû
ANDû,LOYDSûISûCREATINGûAûaMû
FUND (^)