Speaking of the Moor : From "Alcazar" to "Othello"

(やまだぃちぅ) #1

  1. Ray, 33. See also Gillies, 104.

  2. Loomba, Shakespeare, Race, and Colonialism, 84 ; emphasis added.

  3. Loomba, Shakespeare, Race, and Colonialism, 84.

  4. Loomba, Shakespeare, Race, and Colonialism, 84 ; emphasis added.

  5. Compare Ray, on the interpretation of this conflict and this claim, 33 – 34.

  6. Ray, 33 ; Gillies, 104.

  7. Loomba, Shakespeare, Race, and Colonialism, 84 ; Virginia Vaughan, “The Con-
    struction of Barbarism,” 175.

  8. In efforts to reverse this editorial tendency, Bate argues that, although “the cou-
    plet form suggests a self-contained aside,” “it would not be out of character for Saturninus
    to speak these lines publicly”; note to 1.1.265–66.

  9. On Edward II, see my discussion in Spectacles of Strangeness, 143 – 72. See also
    Gregory W. Bredbeck, Sodomy and Interpretation: Marlowe to Milton(Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell
    University Press, 1999 ), 48 – 77.

  10. See Bate’s note to 1. 1. 321.

  11. From Bate’s note to 1. 1. 467 – 68 andThe Oxford English Dictionary Online(Ox-
    ford: Oxford University Press, 2007 ).

  12. See Bate’s note to 1. 1. 499 on the division of the act, which usually precedes Aaron’s
    first speech.

  13. Compare Loomba, Shakespeare, Race, and Colonialism, 84 , who argues that
    Tamora’s relation with Aaron sets her apart from the Goths and the Romans.

  14. Christopher Miller, 6.

  15. Loomba, Shakespeare, Race, and Colonialism, 81 , assigns Aaron a “servile status”;
    see 79 – 82. See also Habib, who reads Aaron as a “colonized black subject” ( 109 ), limited
    by “his memory of her past colonization of him as her slave” ( 110 ).

  16. Greenblatt’s contention that Shakespeare anticipates Freud is still, I think, persua-
    sive; “Psychoanalysis and Renaissance Culture,” in Learning to Curse: Essays in Early Mod-
    ern Culture(New York: Routledge, 1990 ), 131 – 45.

  17. On “dull,” see Bate’s note to 1. 1. 195.

  18. See Bate’s note to 2. 2. 293 – 94.

  19. Barker provocatively uncovers the suppressed violence in the clown scene, though
    he argues that the violence is “naturalized” by its “occlusion” ( 255 ).

  20. See Bate’s note to 5. 1. 122.

  21. The translation is Bate’s; see note to 4. 2. 20 – 21.

  22. We see signs here of humanist educational practice, whereby students ingested
    fragments of texts, quite apart from context. See Mary Thoms Crane, Framing Authority:
    Sayings, Self, and Society in Sixteenth-Century England(Princeton, N.J.: Princeton Univer-
    sity Press, 1993 ), esp. 53 – 76. Lily’s Grammar, in which the verse appears, depends in part
    on the practice of reading through idioms and imitating the structure of figures; see Crane,
    87 – 88.

  23. Joyce E. Chaplin, “Race,” in Armitage and Braddick, eds., 155.

  24. According to The New Shorter Oxford English Dictionary, “swart” means “wicked,
    iniquitous; baleful, malignant.”


212 notes to pages 75–90

Free download pdf