Constitutionalism in Asia in the Early Twenty-First Century

(Greg DeLong) #1

more controversial than the last ones. It was, as Burma expert and scholar Sean


Turnell put it, a ‘constitutionalized fac ̧ade for ongoing military rule’.
38


Four out of the five parties that dominated the 1990 elections – including the


NLD – refused to participate, citing unjust and biased registration laws. To oversee


the election, the SPDC established the Union Election Commission, whose


seventeen members were either retired generals or had close ties with the SPDC.


The commission’s decisions were final and there were no avenues for judicial


review. The polls were dominated by parties known to be closely linked to the


military junta, such as the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP),


the National Unity Party (NUP) and the Union Solidarity and Development


Association (USDA).


The SPDC claimed a voter turnout of 76 per cent, though it has been suggested


that it may well have been lower than 30 per cent.^39 Restrictive election


laws skewed the election in favour of large parties and it was no surprise that


the military-backed Union Solidarity and Development Party won more than


75 per cent of the seats in both the Amyotha Hluttaw and the Pyithu Hluttaw.


As Turnell stated:


Myanmar’s 2010 elections were flawed by a number of irregularities on


polling day, but their outcome was in any case a foregone conclusion.


In the end, some 37 parties contested the elections, but a number of


other parties (some genuinely independent, some representing ethnic


minorities) as well as individuals were excluded. Among the latter


were political prisoners, including the most famous, Daw Aung San


Suu Kyi...The NDF faced the obstacles that confronted most


participants – high registration fees (around US$ 300 per party and


$ 500 per candidate). Other impediments were the severe restrictions


on freedom of speech and assembly (including election-specific


injunctions against criticism of the Constitution and the polling


process), a lack of access to the media and an absence of free reporting,


and a pervasive environment of fear and intimidation.


40

The first session of the military-dominated legislature was called on 31 January 2011


and U Thein Sein, a Than Shwe prote ́ge ́, was elected president. Thura U Tin Aung


Myint Oo and Dr Sai Mauk Kham were elected vice-presidents. Less than a week


later, on 13 November 2010 , the SPDC released Aung San Suu Kyi from house


arrest. In August 2011 , she held a closed-door meeting with President U Thein Sein


and remarked that while Burma was seeing positive changes, it still had a long way


to go.
41
In September 2011 , the Pyithu Hluttaw passed a law allowing workers to form


unions and assemble peaceably. As censorship was relaxed, the state-owned news-


paper,New Light of Myanmar, ran an article mildly criticising the government.


(^38) Turnell, ‘Myanmar in 2010 ,at 148. (^39) Ibid.
(^40) Ibid., at 149 – 50. (^41) ‘Myanmar sees the light’,Straits Times, 12 September 2011.


228 Tan

Free download pdf