Constitutionalism in Asia in the Early Twenty-First Century

(Greg DeLong) #1

of seats, to form the Royal Government. In addition, members of the Assembly who


intend to form the Royal Government must obtain a vote of confidence from the


Assembly, who must pass the vote by a majority of two-thirds.


The difficulty begins with Article 82. If enough anti-government politicians stay


away from the Assembly, no president of the Assembly can be elected. Without a


president of the National Assembly to recommend a prime minister to the king, no


government can be formed. The operation of these provisions was brought into


sharp relief in the aftermath of the July 2003 general elections in which Hun Sen’s


CPP won seventy-three of the 123 seats in the National Assembly. Despite this


convincing victory, Hun Sen was unable to form a new government because


his party was nine seats short of the constitutional two-thirds majority required to


govern. It took him a whole year to win over FUNCINPEC to form a two-party


coalition.^61 As Robert Albritton noted:


Provisions of the Constitution designed to force warring parties to


collaborate in forming a government are now an obstacle to


democratic consolidation. The two-thirds requirement to organize


the Parliament subjects any party to political blackmail, even after


winning a substantial majority of the seats...The inability of the


majority party to form a government is a source of political, economic,


and social instability that will pose a threat not only to democratic


progress but to the development of the economy and the ability of


Cambodia to integrate into the international community.^62


Article 82 was amended in March 2006 to provide that the election of the president,


vice-president and all members of the various committees be obtained ‘by an


absolute majority vote of all Members of the National Assembly’. In the July


2008 elections for the National Assembly, the CPP won 58 per cent of the


popular vote, translating into ninety of the 123 seats in the Assembly. For the first


time, it could form the government of Cambodia without a coalition.


iv. thailand


Of the countries discussed in this chapter, Thailand has drafted the most consti-


tutions. Since the Chakri kings surrendered absolute power in 1932 , Thailand has


promulgated and discarded seventeen constitutions.
63
The first of these was the


(^61) See Oskar Weggel, ‘Cambodia in 2005 : year of reassurance’ ( 2006 ) 46 ( 1 )Asian Survey 155 at
155 ; and Melanie Beresford, ‘Cambodia in 2004 : an artificial democratization process’
( 2005 ) 45 ( 1 )Asian Survey 134 at 135.
(^62) Robert B. Albritton, ‘Cambodia in 2003 : on the road to democratic consolidation’ ( 2004 )
44 ( 1 )Asian Survey 102 at 109.
(^63) For a brief account of Thailand’s pre- 1932 constitutional history, see Andrew Harding and
Peter Leyland,The Constitutional System of Thailand: A Contextual Analysis(Oxford:
Hart, 2011 ), pp. 1 – 10.


234 Tan

Free download pdf