Enoch and the Mosaic Torah- The Evidence of Jubilees

(Nora) #1

Kelky Coblentz Bautch


mine whether one of the angels joined with Lamech's unnamed wife to fa­
ther the unusual-looking baby (1 En 106:7-8)."
Even while the narratives may not indicate that the women are culpa­
ble in provoking the sexual encounters, the watchers are portrayed as defiled
through these unions (1 En 7:i).^53 Defilement, as in the book of Jubilees, is
the result of the watchers having sexual intercourse with people forbidden to
them.^54 As one sees in Jubilees, itself dependent on these or comparable tra­
ditions, forbidden unions result in troublesome offspring; in the Enochic lit­
erature the problematic progeny are giants who initiate violence and leave as
a legacy their immortal spirits as demons (1 En 6; 7:2-6; 9:7-8; 15). The illicit
nature of the sexual relationship is also reflected in how the Book of the
Watchers refers to the offspring of the union: bastards, half-breeds, and sons
of miscegenation (10:9)."


Women also appear in Enochic texts in association with illicit knowl­
edge, a significant theme that runs throughout this literature.^56 In one of the
strata that make up 1 En 6-11, angels teach the wives sorcery, charms, and the
cutting of roots and plants after they have sexual relations (cf. 7:1; 8:3; 16:3)."



  1. While Enoch selects a mate for his son, Methuselah, the Greek (Chester Beatty-
    Michigan Papyrus) of 1 En 106:1 suggests that Lamech chooses his own wife; this detail sets
    the stage for the remarkable (and troubling) appearance of Noah. One recalls that choosing
    one's mate, from the perspective of Jubilees, could be seen as a careless and dangerous ap­
    proach to matrimony. Cf. Jub 7:20-21; Halpern-Amaru, Empowerment of Women, 38,41-42,
    and above.

  2. Loader observes that the Ethiopic features dammara ("were promiscuous with,"
    "united with," or "mixed with"), whereas Panopolitanus reads uiaivsoSai ("to defile").
    Enoch, Levi, and Jubilees, 12 n. 28. The theme of women defiling the watchers occurs also in
    1 En 9:8; 10:11; and 15:4. For possible interpretations of these occurrences, see Loader, Enoch,
    Levi, and Jubilees, 12-15, and Helge Kvanvig, "Gen 6,3 and the Watcher Story," Hen 25 (2003):
    277-300 (here 291).

  3. Loader, Enoch, Levi, and Jubilees, 15. See also Arcari, "The Myth of the Watchers
    and the Problem of Intermarriage in Jubilees"

  4. See Loader, Enoch, Levi, and Jubilees, 22.

  5. On the theme of illicit knowledge, see A. Yoshiko Reed, Fallen Angels and the His­
    tory of Judaism and Christianity: The Reception of Enochic Literature (Cambridge: Cambridge
    University Press, 2005), 29-49.

  6. The Book of the Watchers includes a third stratum that also takes up illicit knowl­
    edge. In this instance the angel Asael teaches the manufacturing of weapons of war, adorn­
    ments, and cosmetics. These forbidden arts then lead to impiety (1 En 8:1-2). Because Asael
    teaches men the arts, who, in fact, produce adornments and cosmetics for their daughters as
    well as the weapons of war for themselves, I do not see the daughters given special censure in
    the narrative.

Free download pdf